FIVE

General Characteristics of Islam and Shī‘ism

A proper way of looking at Islam is to consider it as a system. Islam is not just a set of scattered beliefs and practices, nor a number of formalities lacking a unifying spirit. It is rather a complete system revealed by God to provide direction for all aspects of human life, throughout the ages and under different conditions. Islam is a system in that it possesses all the elements required to meet the needs of mankind in its universality and entirety. Islam has clearly established ideals and the theoretical and practical means needed to achieve them. The ability of Islam to cope with a very wide range of challenges and difficulties in all different ages and to make steady progress under various cultural, social, economic and practical conditions without losing its identity and integrity is a good sign of the remarkable efficacy of the Islamic system of thought. Muslims are the first to admit that the reason for this success and strength lies in Islam itself and not in themselves or their rulers. In what follows, I will refer to three main characteristics of Islam from the Shī‘a viewpoint or, to express it differently, three main characteristics of Shī‘i Islam: spirituality, rationality and the search for justice. Naturally, there are others that should also ideally be studied, such as dynamism, encouragement of the arts, sciences and other aspects of civilization, and comprehensiveness.

Spirituality

Islam urges its followers to go beyond the material affairs of daily life and to seek out the real nature of human existence with its connections to the unseen world and the spiritual world. In a fragment of poetry attributed to Imām ‘Ali, stress is laid on the greatness of the spiritual world that mankind conceals within itself:

The cure is with you, but you do not see,
And the illness is from you, but you are unaware.
You are the clear book whose
Letters make manifest the hidden.
Do you think you are some small mass
While within you there dwells the greatest world?1

In Islam, belief in resurrection and another world is an ever-present reality linked with one’s approach to this life, not something irrelevant to it and located in the distant future. Alluding to this, the Qur’ān says:

And they know only the apparent aspect of the life in this world and they neglect the hereafter. (30:7)

The Qur’ān invites human beings to investigate the spiritual world within themselves as an entrance to the world of spirituality:

We will soon show them Our signs in the horizons and in their own souls, until it becomes clear to them that it is the Truth. (41:35)

And there are signs on the earth for those who are certain. And in your own souls [too]; will you not then see? (51:20, 21)

In a well-known ḥadīth, the Prophet Muḥammad formulates as follows the relationship between one’s knowledge of one’s self to one’s knowledge of God:

Whoever knows himself [or his soul] knows his Lord.2

The obverse of this relationship, i.e. the relationship of one’s knowledge of God to one’s knowledge of one’s self, is referred to directly in the Qur’ān:

And be not like those who forgot God, so He made them forget their own souls; these it is that are the transgressors. (59:19)

Therefore, the knowledge of the most valuable being according to any religion, i.e. God, is linked to one’s knowledge of one’s own reality, which by no means can be identified with the physical aspect of humanity, the body.3 It also has to be noted that the mere knowledge of one’s self is not sufficient. Having known the reality of the self, one has to take care of it by educating, training and purifying it. The process of cultivating spirituality can be summed up as follows:

  1. attention to one’s self (in contrast to negligence and immersion in material life);

  2. knowing one’s self, including its reality, faculties, potentialities and what benefits or harms it;

  3. taking care of one’s self.4

The process of taking care of one’s self involves:

  1. acquiring appropriate beliefs and faith;

  2. refraining from evil deeds and performing acts of piety;

  3. acquiring good characteristics and removing evil ones;

  4. continuing the spiritual journey until one becomes a true servant who meets his Lord.5

Based on the teachings of the Qur’ān and the ḥadīths of the Prophet Muḥammad and his Household, Islam possesses an extremely rich heritage of spirituality built around the above elements. Whoever wishes to familiarize himself with Islamic spirituality must also know that it is a full-fledged system, penetrating all aspects of life. In Islam everything is devised in order to serve the spirituality of man and to facilitate his proximity to God, from religious practices such as praying and fasting to the social system such as Islamic economics, politics and judicial laws. A sample number of the sayings and supplications of the Prophet and his Household regarding the fruits of the spiritual journey and the process of attaining nearness to and meeting God will now be presented.6

Complete Support by God

In a famous ḥadīth, the Prophet reports that he asked God about the status of the believers, and God’s answer included the following:

None of My servants can seek proximity to Me by that which is dearer to Me than things that I have made wājib [obligatory] to him. Then, with the performance of nawāfil [the recommended acts], he continuously attains proximity to Me, so that I love him. When I love him, I will be the ear with which he hears, the eyes with which he sees, and the hand with which he strikes. If he calls Me, I will answer his call, and if he makes a request, I will grant it.7

#### Perfect Knowledge

There are many ḥadīths that indicate that one of the consequences of having attained spiritual nearness to God is to be endowed with great knowledge of the realities of the world, including many mysteries that can never be known through ordinary methods of learning and teaching. Again the Prophet reports God as saying with regard to the servant who has attained proximity to Him:

I will love him when he loves Me and I will make him loved by My creation, and I will open up his inward eyes to My glory and grandeur, and I will not hide from him [the knowledge of] the select of My creation. So in the darkness of night and in the light of day, I will tell him secrets, so that his conversations with creatures and with his companions will be cut off. I will make him hear My words and the words of My angels and I will reveal to him the secret I have hidden from My creation.8

Exclusive Devotion to God

To be cut off from anything other than God means to be free from any reliance on anything other than God, and to see everything as His sign and as a manifestation of His power and grace. The true servants of God live within society while remaining totally mindful of God, and they remember Him continuously. The Qur’ān praises a group of people ‘whom neither business nor trading distract from remembering God, keeping up prayer and paying the zakāh’. (24:37) Imām ‘Ali and other members of the household of the Prophet called upon God, saying:

My God! Make me completely cut off from all else but You, and enlighten the vision of our hearts with the radiance of looking at You, until the vision of our hearts penetrates the veils of light and reaches the Source of Grandeur and sets our spirit to be suspended at the glory of Your sanctity.9

Entrance to the Realm of Light

The above ḥadīths and many others refer to the fact that one of the consequences of progress on the spiritual journey is the elimination of darkness and entrance into the realm of light. This fact is clearly expressed by the Qur’ān.10

Immense Love for God

The mystic is not the one who loves God; rather he is the one who loves God alone, because his love or hatred for anything else is for the sake of God only. He wills and desires only what his Beloved wills and desires. He has no will or desire other than His. The mystic’s love for God permeates his love for anything else.11 Imam Ṣādiq says:

The pure heart is the one that meets its Lord while it is free from anyone else.

Nothing short of reaching God can satisfy the spiritual wayfarer. The Qur’ān says:

Surely! With the remembrance of God hearts come to rest. (13:28)

Imām ‘Ali b. Ḥusayn says:

Nothing will cool my burning thirst, but reaching You; quench my ardour but meeting You; dampen my yearning, but gazing upon Your face; settle me in my settling place without closeness to You.12

Witnessing God in Everything

The mystic is the one who witnesses God in everything. Imām Ḥusayn says:

O my God! Through the variety of Your signs (in the world of being) and the changes in states and conditions, I realized that the purpose is to make Yourself known to me in everything, so that I would not ignore You in anything.13

Imām ‘Ali says:

I saw nothing except that I saw God before it, with it and after it.14

It is obvious that the vision in question, for God, the Almighty, is infinitely exalted beyond the range of the physical eye. The Shī‘a unanimously believe that God cannot be seen by the physical eye, either in this world or in the hereafter.

The foregoing discussion demonstrates that Islamic spirituality is perfectly God-centred. The value of man, the subject of this journey and the best of God’s creation, is defined by the place that he occupies on the path towards God, by the degree that he is either distant from Him or close to Him.

Supplication

One of the manifestations of spirituality in Shī‘i Islam is supplication (du‘ā), a practice much emphasized in the Qur’ān and the ḥadīths of the Prophet and his Household. For example, the Qur’ān says:

Say: My Lord will not pay any attention to you, if you do not pray. (25:77)

If My servant asks you about Me [tell them:] surely I am near. I answer the call of the caller when he calls Me. (2:186)

Call Me! I will answer to You. (40:60)

The Prophet Muḥammad said:

Supplication is the weapon of the believer and the pillar of faith.

The Imāms of the Household of the Prophet said:

The best type of worship is supplication.

Supplication is the core of worship.

Surely supplication is the cure for all types of illness.

Many sayings of the Household of the Prophet discuss different aspects of supplication, such as its meaning and purpose, and instructions on how and when to make supplication, and obstacles to supplications being answered. In addition, there are many short and long texts of supplication narrated from the Imāms of the Household of the Prophet contained in Shī‘a sources. Many volumes have in turn been written by Shī‘a scholars by way of commentary on those texts.

The best-known collection of supplications in Islam as a whole is Al-Ṣaḥīfat al-Sajjādīyah composed by Imām ‘Ali b. Ḥusayn.15 This book is a masterpiece of Islamic spirituality that includes profound theological, philosophical and psychological facts as well.16 What has added to the significance of this book is that all those supplications belong to one of the most critical times in the early history of Islam, i.e. the period after the martyrdom of Imām Ḥusayn, the grandson of the Prophet, and 72 of his family members and followers. Imām ‘Ali b. Ḥusayn (the son of Imām, also known as Zayn al-‘Ābidīn, ‘the adornment of the worshippers’) had been seriously ill during the events at Karbalā’ (61 AH), and he was taken captive along with Zaynab, the granddaughter of the Prophet, and other women andchildren of his family. From his eventual release until the end of his life or, more precisely, until his martyrdom, the Imām and his followers were subjected to confinement and surveillance. Under these circumstances, composing texts of supplication served as an appropriate means for communicating pure Islamic teachings and spirituality. One can again see how spirituality in Islam is interwoven with social responsibilities; a true Muslim in his most private moments of prayer cannot neglect what is happening around him or overlook his social responsibilities.

Rationality

One of the most important issues in religious studies and in the philosophy of religion is to define the role of reason and its relation to revelation. As we have seen, Islam regards reason as one of the greatest blessings bestowed by God on human beings. It is by means of reason that we understand ourselves and the world around us. It is by means of reason that we realize the necessity of investigating our origin and the One who has created us. If we had no reason, we would not be liable for our acts or beliefs. In Shī‘i Islam in particular, great emphasis has always been placed on reason and the rational sciences. This emphasis derives from the Qur’ān and the traditions of the Prophet and the Imāms of his household. The Qur’ān says in several verses:

Surely there are signs in this for those who ponder. (13:4; 16:12; 30:24)

The Qur’ān also condemns more than once those who do not think or use their reason. The following two traditions, selected from the large number of ḥadīths available on the subject, show the place of reason in Shī‘a belief. Imām Ṣādiq says:

Whoever has intellect has faith and whoever has faith will enter Paradise.17

With reason one comes to understand the truth, to believe in Islam and follow the teachings of the Prophet, and consequently one will be able to enter Paradise. In an insightful ḥadīth addressing one of his companions, Hishām b. Ḥakam, Imām Mūsā Kāẓim said:

With reason God completes His proof. God has equipped His prophets with the ability of expressing their ideas in a way that all people can understand. God showed people His lordship through reasons. Then the Imām recited this verse of the Glorious Qur’ān: ‘Your God is the One God, there is no god but God who is the Compassionate the Merciful … Surely in the creation of the heavens and the earth and in the alternation of days and night, and in the ships that move in the sea, and in the rain that descends from the sky to bring life on the earth, and all kinds of animals that God has spread over the earth, and also in the movement of the wind and the clouds which God has kept between the earth and the sky – in all these there are signs for those who are thoughtful.’ Then the Imām said: ‘Allah has made these signs a proof to show people that they have a Creator Who arranges everything for them and Who directs everything, because God then says ‘surely there are signs in these facts for those who use their reason’.18

Many other references to the Qur’ān are made in this tradition, which shows that God in His final message considers reason as the only means by which human beings become responsible and come to understand the truth. All questions on the Day of Judgement are proportionate to the rational capacity of people. Those who have been given greater intelligence will be questioned more deeply than ordinary people.

One of the key functions of reason is to direct us towards the truth of religion. The Shī‘a believe that the exercise of reason is the only way a person can come to understand that God exists, that He has sent certain people as His messengers and that resurrection will take place. Indeed, it is obligatory for every Muslim to examine and question his beliefs until he attains certainty, and to be able to support his beliefs with valid logical arguments. Muslims are not allowed to say that they believe in God for no particular reason or call themselves Muslim simply because their parents are Muslim or because they were born in a Muslim community. Faith is a matter of reasoning, not of imitation. Everyone is advised to secure his faith with sound arguments. In this way, one can have complete confidence in his belief, and nothing can cause him to doubt it.

Another issue that arises in connection with the function of reason is in understanding moral good and bad or what is right and wrong.19 This has been an important topic of concern for all religious traditions, especially Christianity and Islam. According to the ‘Divine Command Theory’, ‘good’ or ‘morally right’ means ‘commanded by God’, and ‘bad’ or ‘morally wrong’ means ‘forbidden by God.’20 On the other hand, some theologians have also argued for a rational approach to ethics. They believed that there are independent criteria of good and bad that can be understood by our reason. In other words, the religious believer does not have exclusive access to moral truth; God has made all people rational. For both believer and non-believer, making a reasonable moral judgement is a matter of listening to reason and following it. God’s commands are not arbitrary and we can exercise rational methods to discover moral norms. Among Muslim theologians, the Ash‘arites held the former view, and the Mu‘tazilites and Shī‘a held the latter.21

According to the Ash‘arites, all values are determined by the will of God, and moral concepts such as ‘good’ and ‘right’ have no meaning other than ‘what God wills’ or ‘what is commanded by God’. The words ‘good’ and ‘right’ have no objective meaning. According to Shī‘a and Mu‘tazilites, however, values such as justice and goodness do possess a real existence, independent of anyone’s will, even God’s, since values are objective.

Based on the above issue, another controversy arose concerning the question of whether good and evil are perceived rationally (al-ḥusn wa’l-qubḥ al-‘aqlīyān) or through revelation. The Shī‘a and the Mu‘tazilites believed that good and evil are objective and therefore can be known rationally. ‘Allamah al-Ḥillī, a great Shī‘a scholar, in his comments on Al-Yāqūt by al-Nawbakhtī, writes:

The principle on which the problems concerning justice depend is that God is All-Wise; He never commits an evil action, nor does He fail to perform any obligatory (wājib) action. When this principle is proved, questions concerning justice, such as the goodness of obligation (taklīf), the necessity of grace (luṭf) and the like are constructed upon it. And since this principle depends on the knowledge of good and evil and their rationality, the author [i.e. al-Nawbakhtī]) started his discussion with these.22

Elsewhere he writes:

Imāmites and their followers, the Mu‘tazilites, believe that the goodness and evilness of some actions are known by reason evidently, such as our knowledge of the goodness or benefit of telling the truth or evilness of harmful lies, which no reasonable person doubts, and his certainty about this is no weaker than his certainty about the need of a contingent being [in its existence] for a cause or about the equality of two things that are each equal to a third thing. They believe that there are some actions the goodness or evil of which may be perceived through reflection, such as the goodness of telling the harmful truth and the evil of beneficial lies, and finally that there are some actions on which reason is unable to make judgement, and their goodness or evil is to be declared by the religious law (Shar‘), such as [how to perform] acts of worship.23

On the other hand, the Ash‘arites deny the rationality of goodness and evil altogether. Shahrestānī in his Al-Milal wa al-Niḥal describes their view as follows:

All obligations are to be learnt from revelation. Reason (al-‘aql) does not make anything obligatory and does not make anything deserve to be considered good or bad. Thus, knowing God becomes possible by reason and becomes obligatory (wājib) by scripture (sam‘). God, the Most High, says: ‘We have never chastised unless We have despatched some messenger.’ (The Qur’ān, 17:15) Similarly, gratitude to the blessing-giver, rewarding the obedient and punishing the disobedient become obligatory (wājib) by revelation and not by reason.24

By contrast, the Shī‘a and the Mu‘tazilites have argued that we have been given the power to understand what is good and what is evil. Even those who do not believe in any religion understand at least basic moral values and are therefore morally responsible. If goodness and evil were determined only by religion and not conceivable by reason, unbelievers would not recognize them today or in advance of becoming acquainted with revelation. But we know that there are many values and moral principles shared by theists and atheists. ‘Abd al-Jabbār, a great Mu‘tazilite theologian, says: ‘Any sane person knows his obligations even though he does not know that there is a Commander and Forbidder.’25

The Shī‘a and the Mu‘tazilites have also argued that if we did not have such independent understanding, we could not decide on the veracity of the claims made by the prophets, because one might think it possible for God give miraculous powers to false prophets. It is our reason which tells us that misleading people is wrong and that God, the Wise, the Merciful, Who is rationally proven to exist, is known never to do anything wrong. It would be circular to say to those who have not yet found the truth of religion that God never misleads, because He Himself or the Qur’ān has proclaimed this to be the case.

The Qur’ān itself in fact implies in many statements that the knowledge of what is obligatory, good and evil is accessible to everyone: ‘Surely God bids to justice and good-doing and giving to kinsmen, and He forbids indecency, dishonour and insolence.’ (16:92) These virtues and vices must have been recognized as such prior to revelation. The objectivity of ethical values is asserted throughout the Qur’ān. For instance, the repeated commands of God to do what is right would be empty of force and spirit, if all they meant was ‘to do what He commands you to do’. It would be even harder to make sense of statements that God is always just to His servants on the supposition that ‘just’ means ‘commanded by God’.

None of this means, of course, that humans are not in need of religious guidance. The argument is rather that in order to benefit fully from religious guidance, humans have been endowed with reason, and it is only when they are thoughtful and rational that they can comprehend revelation. The truth of religion and the principles of morality are understood by reason, but there is much more to be learnt from revelation. According to Shī‘a thinkers, religion can provide us with a fuller and more comprehensive account of morality, and moreover motivates us to observe moral requirements.

On the place of intellectual sciences among the Shī‘a, Yann Richard writes:

Today, however, one of the originalities of Shī‘ite Islam is to recognize that metaphysical speculation and philosophical discourse have a certain place in religious knowledge. The Centre for Theological Studies at Qom [Qum] is certainly the only place of Islamic studies in the world where one dares comment on the philosophical treatises of Aristotle or Avicenna, and where the post-Platonic philosophical tradition has remained alive. Ayatollah Khomeini was known at Qom up till the beginning of the 1950s for his philosophy course.26

On the continuity and development of the philosophical tradition, S. M. H. Ṭabāṭabā’ī (1892–1981), himself the most celebrated contemporary master of Islamic philosophy, writes:

In the same way that from the beginning Shī‘ism played an effective role in the formation of Islamic philosophical thought, it was also a principal factor in the further development and propagation of philosophy and the Islamic sciences … In the same manner, in the other intellectual sciences, there appeared many outstanding figures such as Naṣīr al-Dīn Ṭūsī (who was both philosopher and mathematician) and Birjandī, who was also an outstanding mathematician.

All the sciences, particularly metaphysics or theosophy (falsafah-i ilāhī or ḥikmat-i ilāhī), made major advances thanks to the indefatigable endeavour of Shī‘ite scholars. This fact can be seen if one compares the works of Naṣīr al-Dīn Ṭūsī, Shams al-Dīn Turkah, Mir Dāmād and Ṣadr al-Dīn Shirāzī with the writings of those who came before them.27

The Search for Justice

One of the principal doctrines of Shī‘a Islam is justice. God is just and never does anything unjust or contrary to the criteria of justice. Divine justice is known by reason and confirmed by revelation. The Qur’ān says:

We shall set up scales for justice on Resurrection Day, and no soul will be dealt with unjustly in any way. (21:47)

God treats human beings with justice and wants them to deal with each other justly and establish justice in society. The issue of divine justice is not merely theological, for it has clear and significant practical implications. All the prophets were sent to establish social justice:

We have sent Our messengers with explanation, and sent the Book and the Balance down along with them, so that mankind may conduct themselves with all fairness. (57:25)

Surely God commands justice, benevolence and giving to the kindred. (16:90)

It is a duty for everyone to implement justice in both his individual and his social life. A Muslim is one who is just to himself,28 to his spouse and children29 and to everybody else, including his enemies.30 According to Shī‘a jurisprudence, there are many religious or socio-political positions that require the position holder to be just. For example, those who lead the congregational or Friday prayers, witnesses, judges, religious authorities and statesmen all must be just.

In Islam, the government is envisaged as an irreplaceable means of establishing and safeguarding social justice. A just society can be maintained only by fair distribution of power and wealth. The following are some ḥadīths relevant to this issue from the Prophet and his Household.

  1. In the year of the Conquest of Mecca a woman from a wealthy and affluent family committed a theft. The Prophet decided to punish her. Members of her family and other people went to the Prophet and asked for her to be exempted. The Prophet did not accept their pleas and gathered the people together, saying that the previous nations had perished because they had discriminated against the poor and lower class people.

  2. Explaining why he accepted the Caliphate after the death of the third Caliph, Imām ‘Ali says:

    Behold, by Him who split the grain [to grow] and created living beings, if people had not come to me and supporters had not exhausted the argument, and if there had been no pledge of Allāh with the learned to the effect that they should not acquiesce in the gluttony of the oppressor and the hunger of the oppressed, I would have cast the rope of Caliphate on its own shoulders, and would have given the last one the same treatment as the first. Then you would have seen that, in my view, this world of yours is no better than the sneezing of a goat.31

  3. Describing his plans and policies to reform the previously unjust distribution of resources, Imām ‘Ali said that he would return all usurped possessions to the public treasury and to their real owners:

    By Allāh, even if I find that by such money women have been married or slave women have been purchased, I will reclaim it because there is a wide scope in the dispensation of justice, and he who finds it hard to act justly will find it harder to deal with injustice.32

  4. Once Imām ‘Ali saw a necklace on the neck of his daughter. He asked where it came from. She replied that she had borrowed it from the treasury. Imām summoned the treasurer and asked him why he had given her the necklace. He replied that it was a registered loan. Then Imām released him and said that if it had been otherwise, he would have certainly punished her.

According to Islam, rulers must be just in their individual lives as well as in their social lives. They must fulfil all their personal duties as well as their social responsibilities, including respect for the rights of their citizens. They must observe justice in both personal and administrative affairs. They must in addition establish social justice and make sure that neither their agents nor ordinary citizens violate standards of justice. Imām ‘Ali said:

If I had so wanted, I could have very easily found ways and means to provide for myself the purest honey, the best variety of wheat and the finest silk clothes that could be woven. But inordinate cravings cannot overcome me and greediness cannot persuade me to acquire the best provisions, when in the Ḥijāz and Yemen there may be people who have no hope of obtaining a piece of bread and who have never satisfied their hunger fully. I cannot satiate myself when there are people around me whom hunger and thirst keep restless and agonized. Do you want me to be like that person about whom somebody has very aptly said, ‘Is this disease not enough for you that you keep on sleeping with your stomach full, and around you there are such starving mouths that will greedily eat even dried goatskin’?33

Imām ‘Ali also said:

Certainly, Allāh, the Sublime, has made it obligatory on true leaders that they maintain themselves at the level of the humble so that the poor do not cry out over their poverty.34

One of the features of a proper political system in Islam is that people should be able to protest against any breach of Islamic laws or violation of human rights. In his letter to the newly appointed governor of Egypt, Mālik al-Ashtar, Imām ‘Ali writes:

Out of your hours of work, fix a time for the dissatisfied and for those who want to approach you with their grievances. During this time you should do no other work but hear them and pay attention to their complaints and grievances. For this purpose you must arrange a public audience for them, during which, for the sake of Allah, you must treat them with kindness, courtesy and respect. Do not let your army and police be in the audience hall at such times so that those who have grievances against your rule may speak to you freely, unreservedly and without fear.

All this is a necessary factor of your rule because I have often heard the Prophet(s) saying: ‘A nation or government where the rights of the depressed, destitute and suppressed are not observed and where the mighty and powerful persons are not forced to grant them their rights cannot achieve salvation.’35

Muslims must not be indifferent towards wrong acts and unjust behaviour by others; they must be particularly sensitive towards crimes committed by the state, for criminal rulers are the worst of all criminals.36

When rulers flout Islamic law or morality, they must be advised to desist, failing which Muslims must protest and rise up against them. The Qur’ān says:

You are the best of the nations raised up for [the benefit of] men; you enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong and believe in God. (3:110)

God does not love the public utterance of hurtful speech, unless [it be] by one to whom injustice has been done; and God is Hearing, Knowing. (4:148)

The Prophet Muḥammad said: ‘The best struggle (jihād) is to utter words of justice in front of an unjust leader.’37 He also said: ‘You must certainly enjoin the good and prohibit the bad; otherwise the evildoers will rule over you such that even when the good people among you pray, their prayers will not be answered.’38

The Imāms of the Household of the Prophet constantly resisted oppression by unjust rulers. A sufficient proof of their readiness to undergo all sorts of sacrifice is the simple fact that they all met their deaths through killing (except, of course, the Twelfth Imām who is in Occultation). Many of their followers were also imprisoned or murdered.

The history of the Shī‘a is full of struggles and revolutionary movements calling for the implementation of Islamic laws and justice. The most striking and inspiring incident in the entire history of the Shī‘a was the tragedy of Karbalā’. Explaining his purpose in refusing to pay allegiance to Yaziīd (the usurpatory Caliph) and rising up against him, Imām Ḥusayn said:

I see death as salvation, and life with the oppressors as misfortune.39

In his Tārīkh al-Umam wa al-Mulūk, Ṭabarī narrates from Imām Ḥusayn:

O people, whoever witnesses an unjust ruler permitting acts prohibited by God, breaking divine covenants, acting against the Sunnah of the Prophet and treating people sinfully and with enmity – whoever witnesses all this and does not protest in word or in deed will certainly be treated by God in the same way as that oppressor.40

The tragic events at Karbalā’ and their aftermath showed that Islamic society had seriously deviated from the way of the Prophet Muḥammad. The only hope for saving Islam and the Sunnah of the Prophet and awakening the people was to shock them by means of a very tragic and thought-provoking event, which was the very great sacrifice made by the only surviving grandson of the Prophet. Tens of his relatives and Companions were murdered, and Imām ‘Ali b. Ḥusayn and the women and children of the Prophet’s family were taken as captives. On his way to Karbalā’, Imām Ḥusayn saw the Prophet in his dream telling him that God wished to see him martyred and the women taken captive.

Many people were shaken from their slumber by the tragedy. Several uprisings and oppositional movements took place that culminated in the overthrow of the Umayyads. The Abbasid rulers who succeeded them based their claim to power in part on a call for avenging members of the Household of the Prophet who had been victims of Umayyad oppression. They too, however, deviated from justice, step by step, becoming responsible for the deaths of several Imāms of the Household of the Prophet and many other innocent people. The Shī‘a continued their opposition to injustice in whatever way they could.

Imām Ḥusayn proved that martyrdom is both a sacred goal and an efficient instrument for safeguarding Islamic principles and values and defeating injustice, oppression and heresies. This is why the Prophet said:

Ḥusayn is from me and I am from him.41

Imām Ḥusayn was obviously from the Prophet in the sense that he was his grandson. No such biological argument can, however, be advanced to explain why the Prophet considered himself as being from Imām Ḥusayn. It seems that the Prophet was referring to the fact that the survival of Islam and his Prophetic message would require the brave uprising of Ḥusayn. If Ḥusayn had not been there and his struggle had not happened, true Islam would not have continued:

If the religion of Muḥammad cannot continue except with my martyrdom, then O swords do embrace me.

The concept of a saviour known as al-Mahdi also relates to the theme of Islamic justice in Islam, especially Shī‘a Islam. The foremost task of al-Mahdi and his followers, the first item on their agenda, will be to ‘fill the earth with justice’, a phrase that occurs in many ḥadīths. For example, the Prophet said:

We [I and my family] are members of a Household, for whom God has chosen the life of the Hereafter over the life of this world; and the members of my Household shall suffer great affliction. They will be forcefully expelled from their homes after my death; then there will come people from the East carrying black flags, and they will ask for some good to be given to them, but they shall be refused service; accordingly, they will wage war and emerge victorious, and will be offered that which they desired in the first place, but they will refuse to accept it, and will hand it over to a man from my family who will appear to fill the Earth with justice as it has been filled with corruption. So whoever is alive at that time should go and join them, even if they have to crawl across ice, for among them will be the Vicegerent of Allah (Khalīfat-ul-lāh), al-Mahdi.42