THREE

Doctrines

Despite their differences, Muslims have throughout history shared broad agreement not only on many of the principles of Islam, but also on many of its practices. The Qur’ān and the great personality of the Prophet, on the one hand, and the sincere love and devotion of all Muslims towards them both, on the other hand, have unified Muslims and made of them a real nation that has its own identity, heritage, aims, objectives and destiny. The hostility of the enemies of Islam, who have always tried to uproot Islam as a whole, and the challenges of the age have also helped to awaken and strengthen the sense of unity and brotherhood among Muslims. The Qur’ānic and Prophetic call for unity and brotherhood has always been echoed by the great leading personalities of the different schools of thought in Islam.

With respect to beliefs, all Muslims share the belief in God and His unity, in the prophets in general and the mission of the Prophet Muḥammad in particular, which is to deliver the final message of God for human beings, together with resurrection and the just and equal treatment of everybody on the Day of Judgement. These are the most fundamental principles of Islam, which are agreed upon by all Muslims. An outsider’s view of the extent of the agreement between Shī‘a and Sunni Muslims is expressed in the following passage:

Since the Iranian Revolution everyone knows that Shī‘ites are Muslims, who, like the Sunnis, respect the central dogma of the oneness of God, the same sacred writing [the Koran], the same Prophet Muḥammad, the same belief in the resurrection followed by the last Judgement and the same fundamental obligations, prayer, fasting, pilgrimage, almsgiving and jihād1 [holy war]. These common points are more important than the differences: there is no longer any theoretical objection to a Shī‘ite performing his prayers with a Sunni or vice versa, although many difficulties have existed in the past and in practice still remain.2

In what follows, we will first provide a short account of Islamic doctrines and then examine the articles of faith enumerated above in greater detail. Finally, the distinctive beliefs of the Shī‘a will be expounded.

A Brief Description of Islam

In reply to a request from al-Ma’mūn, the Abbasid Caliph of his time, that he write for him a brief description of the essence of Islam, Imām ‘Ali b. Mūsā al-Riḍā (d. 203 AH) affirmed the following:

Truly, the essence of Islam is:

to bear witness that there is no god but Allah, the only one and absolutely unique God who is impenetrable, self-subsisting, hearing, seeing, omnipotent, eternal, self-existent, everlasting, knowing such that He is never ignorant of anything, powerful such that He never fails, rich such that He never needs, just in that He never oppresses and truly He is the Creator of everything. There is nothing like Him. He has no similar, no opposite, no peer and no equal and truly He is the object of worship, prayer, hope and fear.

And it is to bear witness that truly Muḥammad is His servant, His messenger, His trusted one, His chosen one, the best among His people, the master of the messengers, the Seal of the prophets and the most excellent creature. There is no prophet after him and no alteration in his religion and no change in his law (Sharī‘ah) and truly whatever Muḥammad b. ‘Abdullāh has brought is the obvious truth [and it is to acknowledge him and all messengers, prophets and proofs of Allah before him] and to acknowledge his Book, the truthful, the splendid, which is such that ‘no falsehood shall approach it from either in front or behind; a revelation from one [who is] the Wise, the Praiseworthy’3 and truly the Qur’ān is superior to all the books and is true from the beginning to the end. We believe in its muḥkam and mutashābih, ‘āmm and khāṣṣ, promise and threat, the abrogating and the abrogated, its narratives and its reports. No creature is able to bring something similar to it.

And it is to bear witness that the guide after him and the witness over the believer and the upholder of Muslims’ affairs and the speaker on behalf of the Qur’ān and the one knowledgeable of its laws, his brother, his successor, executor of his will, his guardian and the one who was to him as Hārūn was to Mūsā is ‘Ali b. Abū Ṭālib, the commander of believers and the leader of the pious, the best successor and the heir of the knowledge of the prophets and messengers, and after him Ḥasan and Ḥusayn, the ‘two masters of the youths of Paradise’ and then ‘Ali b. Ḥusayn, the pride of those who worship, then Ja‘far b. Muḥammad al-Sadiq [the truthful] the heir to the knowledge of the successors, then Mūsā b. Ja‘far al-Kāẓim, then ‘Ali b. Mūsā al-Riḍā, then Muḥammad b. ‘Ali, then ‘Ali b. Muḥammad, then Ḥasan b. ‘Ali, then al-Ḥujjah, the one who rises, the awaited.

I bear witness to their successorship and Imāmate and that the earth will never be empty of the presence of the divine witness (ḥujjah) upon His people at any age, and that they are the firmest handhold and Imāms of guidance and the witnesses over the people of the world until the end of the world. They are the interpreters of the Qur’ān and the speakers on behalf of the Prophet and whoever dies without knowing them has died in ignorance. Their faith consists of piety, knowledge, truthfulness, prayer, uprightness, striving, to return the trust [given in safekeeping] back to their owners, be they good or bad, long prostrations, fasting during the day, worship during the night, refraining from the forbidden, waiting for deliverance (faraj) with patience, good consolation and nobility of companionship.

Then the Imām went on to elucidate the practical laws of Islam.

Principles of Religion

Unity of God

The Islamic faith is formulated by the declaration of two truths: that there is no god (i.e. none worthy of worship) but God (Allāh) and that Muḥammad is His messenger. (LĀ ILĀHA IL-LAL-LĀH MUḤAMMADUR-RASŪ-LUL-LĀH). Muslims believe that Allah is One. He has no partner or children. He is the Beginning and He is the End. He is Omnipotent, Omniscient and Omnipresent. He is closer to man than his jugular vein, but He cannot be seen by the eyes or encompassed by the intellect. In a supplication, Imām ‘Ali says:

O God, verily I ask Thee by Thy Name, in the name of Allah, the All-merciful, the All-compassionate, O Possessor of Majesty and Splendour, the Living, the Self-subsistent, the Eternal, there is no God other than Thee.

Prophethood

God has created mankind wisely and purposefully (51:56). He has given man reason and free will to find his way towards his perfection and happiness. He has also supplemented human reason with divine revelation. Through His wisdom and justice, He has not left any people or corner of the world without guidance; He has sent prophets to all nations to instruct and guide them. (10:47 and 16:36)

The first prophet was Adam and the last was Muḥammad, the Seal of the Prophets (33:40). The Qur’ān mentions 25 of the prophets and states that there were many more. (40:78) Through indications contained in ḥadīths, Muslims believe there have been 124,000 prophets. Among those mentioned in the Qur’ān are Adam, Noah, Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac, Lot, Jacob, Joseph, Job, Moses, Aaron, Ezekiel, David, Solomon, Jonah, Zachariah, John the Baptist, Jesus and Muḥammad. Among them, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muḥammad had a universal mission and brought specific codes of law. They are called Ulū al-‘Azm, ‘possessors of great determination.’

Other than the Qur’ān itself, the Qur’ān speaks of four revealed books: the Book of Abraham (87:19); the Psalms of David (4:163 and 17:55); the Torah of Moses (2:87, 3:3 and 4, 6:91 and 154); and the Gospel of Jesus (5:46).

A Muslim must believe in all the revealed books (2:4 and 285) and in all the prophets. (4:152) As we will see later, the Shī‘a also believe that all the prophets were necessarily infallible and sinless both prior to and during their mission.

Resurrection

The world will come to an end on the Day of Resurrection (Qiyāmah) or Judgement. All men will be resurrected and presented before God, Who will decide their individual fates according to their beliefs and deeds in this world. There will be rewards for the good and punishments for the bad. (22:1, 2, 6–10; 3:185; 6:62; 98:6–8; 99:6–8; 101:4–11) God will treat people with justice but the dominant factor in the administration of His Justice will be His Mercy. (6:12)

Note: Although all Muslims believe in the above principles of Islam, there is a slight difference in their articulation of beliefs and practices. Shī‘a Muslims articulate the above beliefs as principles or roots of the religion (Uṣūl al-Dīn) and the acts of worship to follow as practices or branches of the religion (Furū‘ al-Dīn). The reason for such an articulation is that those beliefs are the most fundamental aspect of the religion and the criteria for being considered a Muslim. However, the mandatory acts of worship are implications of being faithful, since genuine faith manifests itself in practices. Sunni Muslims usually present the declaration of Islam (kalimah) –consisting of bearing witness that there is no god but God (Allāh) and that Muḥammad is His Messenger – together with four acts of worship, i.e. the daily prayer, fasting, pilgrimage to Mecca and almsgiving, as the Five Pillars of Faith. They consider other acts of worship such as enjoining the good and prohibiting the bad, and struggle (jihād) as obligatory acts, but do not include them in the Pillars of Faith.

Shī‘a Doctrines

Having presented an outline of general Islamic beliefs, we will now expand on some of the doctrines of Shī‘i Islam in greater detail. Some of these doctrines are, of course, shared by some non-Shī‘a Muslims as well, at least in principle if not in detail. The reason for singling out these doctrines here is their centrality to Shī‘i thought and belief; whoever believes in all of them can be identified as Shī‘a.

Love for the Prophet Muḥammad

Like other Muslims, the Shī‘a have a great love for the Prophet Muḥammad. They see in him the perfect model of entire reliance on God, profound knowledge of God, ultimate devotion to God, sincere obedience to the divine will, the noblest character, and a source of compassion and mercy for all mankind. It was not accidental that he was chosen by God to deliver His final and most perfect message for humanity. As suggested earlier, the ability to receive divine revelation presupposes the possession of a very high calibre, and the ability to receive the most perfect revelation of all presupposes the highest calibre of all.

The personal character and behaviour of the Prophet contributed greatly to the progress of Islam. He was known to be an honest, trustworthy and pious person from childhood. During his prophethood, he always lived by his principles and values. In times of ease as well as difficulty, security as well as fear, peace as well as war, victory as well as defeat, he always manifested humility, justice and confidence. He was so humble that he never admired himself, never felt superior to others and never lived a life of luxury. Both when he was alone and powerless as well as when he ruled the Arab peninsula and Muslims were wholeheartedly following him and taking every drop of his ablution water, he behaved in the same way. He lived very simply and always with the people, especially the poor. He had no palace or court or guard. When he was sitting with his companions no one could distinguish him from others by the place where he was seated or the clothes he was wearing. It was only his words and spirituality that distinguished him from the others.

He was so just that he never ignored the rights of anyone, even his enemies. He exemplified in his life the Qur’ānic command, ‘O you who believe! Be upright for God, bearers of witness with justice, and let not hatred of a people incite you not to act equitably; act equitably, that is nearer to piety.’ (5:8)

Before battles, he always gave instructions to his soldiers not to harm women, children, old people and those who surrendered themselves, not to destroy farms and gardens, not to chase those who had escaped from the war front, and he enjoined them always to be kind to their captives. Just before his death, he announced in the mosque: ‘Whoever feels that I am in debt to him or I have not observed his rights, please come forward and claim his right.’ The Muslims wept as they were reminded of all the services that the Prophet had rendered them and the troubles he had undergone in order to guide them. They knew that he never gave any priority to his own needs and never preferred his rest and convenience to that of others. They therefore delivered statements of deep gratitude and respect. But one man stood up and said: ‘You owe me something. Before one of the battles you were arranging the soldiers in a row and your stick hit me. Now, I want retaliation.’ Without any hesitation the Prophet told one of his close companions to go to his home and bring the same stick and asked the man to retaliate by hitting him. But the man said: ‘Your stick hit the skin of my stomach.’ Therefore, the Prophet lifted his shirt so that he could hit the skin. Instead of doing so, the man suddenly kissed his body. The man’s whole motivation for claiming the right to retaliate may have been to kiss the Prophet, out of respect and love.

The Prophet was so confident that he never developed any doubt about his mission. The hostility of the polytheists manifested itself in the torture, assassination and murder of Muslims, the confiscation of their properties and the spreading of rumours ascribing madness or magic to the Prophet; but none of this ever stopped him. Imām ‘Ali, the brave soldier of Islam and the conqueror of Khaybar, says that whenever battle became fierce, Muslims would take refuge with the Prophet.4

The Prophet was so blessed and beloved that God sent His blessing upon him wherever he was. According to ḥadīth, other prophets were informed of his exalted position with God and on some occasions they asked God to grant their requests for his sake. There are many ḥadīths referring to this, in both Shī‘a and non-Shī‘a sources. For example, al-Ḥākim al-Nīshābūrī and others narrate from ‘Umar that Adam said to God: ‘O My Lord, I ask you to forgive me for the sake of Muḥammad.’ God told him: ‘O Adam, how did you know of Muhammad when I have not yet created him?’ Adam replied:

O My Lord, [I know him] because when You created me with Your hand and blew from Your spirit in me, I lifted my head and saw written on the pillars of the Throne, ‘There is no god but God. Muḥammad is the messenger of God.’ Then I knew that the one whose name You have placed next to Yours must be the one most beloved of You.

Then God said: ‘You are right. Surely he is the one dearest to me. Call on me for his sake, and I will forgive you. Were it not for Muḥammad, I would not have created you.’5

Calling Upon the Prophet for Help

Muslims during the life of the Prophet implored him for help. For example, Ahmad b. Ḥanbal, al-Tirmidhī, and Ibn Mājah have narrated that a blind person went to the Prophet and asked him to pray to God that he might cure him. The Prophet said: ‘If you wish I will pray, but if you are willing to be patient it would be better for you.’ The man repeated his request. The Prophet told him to make a proper ablution (wuḍū’) and to say: ‘My Lord! Surely I ask you and I call Your Prophet Muḥammad, the Prophet of mercy. O Muḥammad! Surely I call my God through you in my request so that it can be granted. My Lord! Make Muḥammad my intercessor (shafi‘).’6

Obviously, imploring the Prophet for help continues after his death. According to Islam, death does not imply destruction. Death is a gate to a greater and more intelligent life. The Qur’ān expressly speaks of life after death for all people, and the righteous will have a beatific life after death until they are resurrected on the Day of Judgement and enter eternity. The Qur’ān instructs us not to speak of the martyrs as dead (2:154) or even to think of them as dead (3:169). All humans are alive after death, but the martyrs ‘are alive near God and are provided sustenance from their Lord’. (3:169)

Accordingly, both Shī‘a and Sunni Muslims believe that the Prophet is definitely alive and that his acknowledgement of our calls and his God-given power to help us are not decreased by passing away from the body. Al-Dārimī narrates that the people of Medina were starving, so they went to ‘Ā’ishah, the wife of the Prophet, complaining of their condition. She said:

Look at [and visit] the grave of the Prophet. Make a hole in the roof above the grave towards the sky, so that there remains no barrier between the grave and the sky.

Al-Dārimī adds that the people of Medina acted as she instructed them and then it rained so much that the grass grew and their camels became fat.7 Interestingly, Bukhārī narrates that the Caliph ‘Umar on several occasions asked God for rain for the sake of ‘Abbās who was the uncle of the Prophet, just as he had asked God for rain for the sake of the Prophet himself.8

Love for the Household of the Prophet

Although Muslims were deeply indebted to the Prophet and were prepared to do anything for him, the Prophet did not ask them for anything in return. He did all that he did simply for the sake of God.

Say: I do not ask you for any reward for this. (38:86)

However, God himself asked him to tell people that they should love his household:

Say: I do not ask of you any payment for this but love for my near relatives. (42:23)

This does not contradict the fact that the Prophet did not ask anything for himself, because the beneficiaries of this love were the people themselves. Again the Qur’ān says:

Say: Whatever payment I have asked of you, that is only for yourselves; my reward is only with God. (34:47)

In this way, the Prophet directed the people’s natural feeling of gratitude towards something that would guide them. It is rather like a parent who does everything for his child, such as providing him with food, health care, clothes and money, and then registers him at a school, telling him: ‘I do not want anything in return from you. I only want you to learn from your teacher and follow his advice.’

It is thus clear why the Shī‘a love the Household of the Prophet. This love has been established by the Prophet and indeed by God Himself as ‘the path to the Lord’ (25:57), and the Shī‘a have accordingly turned this love into a way of life.

It has to be noted that the the previous prophets also did not ask for recompense, examples being Noah (26:109, 11:29 and 10:72), Hūd (26:127 and 11:5), Ṣāliḥ (26:145), Lot (26:164) and Shu‘ayb (26:180). Quite apart from the fact that the Prophet Muḥammad had the most difficult task of all the prophets, one striking difference in his case is that he is the only one on record to have been told by God to ask his people to love his Household as their path to their Lord. The reason for this is clear. The Prophet Muḥammad was the Seal of the Prophets and no prophet would come after him. In order to remain on the right path, his followers thereafter needed persons who could preserve and present his pure teachings, especially as they related to the explanation of the Glorious Qur’ān. As seen earlier, this point is very clearly made in the ḥadīths of Thaqalayn and Safīnah, ḥadīths that are accepted by all Muslims.

Muslims love the household of the Prophet not only because they were his relatives or Companions but also because they exemplified all the values preached by the Prophet. There is no doubt among Muslims that the Household of the Prophet was a collective embodiment of the merits and virtues of the Islamic nation. When the Prophet Muḥammad had a dispute with the Christians of Najrān, God revealed to him the following:

Tell anyone who disputes with you in this matter, once knowledge has come to you: ‘Come, let us call our sons and your sons, our women and your women, ourselves and yourselves together; then let us plead, and pray for the curse of God upon the liars.’ (3:61)

All Muslim sources narrate that the Prophet took with him Ḥasan and Ḥusayn, representing Muslim children (abnā’anā – ‘our children’), and Fāṭima, representing Muslim women (nisā’anā – ‘our women’). He also took ‘Ali with him, but as part of his own presence there (anfusanā – ‘ourselves’). There are also authentic ḥadīths confirming the rank of these four individuals. For example, the Prophet said: ‘Fāṭima is part of me. What angers her angers me.’9 He also said: ‘Fāṭima is foremost among the ladies of Paradise.’10 Of Ḥasan and Ḥusayn, the Prophet said: ‘Ḥasan and Ḥusayn are masters of the youths of Paradise’ and ‘Ḥusayn is from me and I am from Ḥusayn.’11 It is also a well-established fact that when the Prophet wanted to establish the covenant of brotherhood (‘ahd al-ukhuwwah) among the Muhājirs and Anṣār in Medina, he chose ‘Ali as his own partner and brother, even though they were both Muhājirs. Moreover, the Prophet said to ‘Ali, Fāṭima, Ḥasan and Ḥusayn: ‘I am at war with those with whom you are at war and at peace with those with whom you are at peace.’12

Love for the Household of the Prophet Muḥammad is thus universally upheld by Muslims of all schools of thought, and it has always been considered as a corollary of faith in and love for the Prophet himself. The Shī‘a have in particular tried to fulfil all the requirements of this love, which has been established in the Qur’ān as a ‘recompense’ commensurate with the mission of the Prophet and as a ‘path to the Lord’.

Companions of the Prophet

Like other Muslims, the Shī‘a have a great respect for the Companions of the Prophet, i.e. those who sincerely embraced Islam and supported the Prophet’s mission with their lives and resources without expecting any reward or position, and who remained loyal to the Prophet in all circumstances, especially after his demise, down to the very end of their lives. The Qur’ān says:

… those who believe in him and honour him and help him, and follow the light which has been sent down with him, these it is that are the successful. (7:157)

And [as for] those who believe and do good, and believe in what has been revealed to Muḥammad, and it is the very Truth from their Lord, He will remove their evil from them and improve their condition. (47:2)

Muḥammad is the Messenger of God and those with him are firm of heart against the unbelievers, compassionate among themselves … To those among them who believe and do good, God has promised forgiveness and a great reward. (48:29)

The Shī‘a love the Companions of the Prophet who manifested the above-mentioned values in their lives, although there is no particular command in the Qur’ān to love them. Nor is love for them presented as a ‘recompense’ for the Prophet’s mission or as ‘a path to one’s Lord’. Admiration for faith and good deeds demands admiration in turn for all who led their lives in faithfulness to God and did good deeds, especially those pioneers who preceded others in embracing Islam and supported Islam at its most critical time. The Qur’ān says:

Those who believed and emigrated and struggled for the sake of God with their wealth and their lives stand much higher in rank with God. Those will be the triumphant. (9:20)

The devout companions of the Prophet not only had to defend Islam against the threats of the polytheists, but also had to be fully alert as regards the hypocrites who had penetrated the Muslim community and were plotting continuously with its external enemies. The Qur’ān says:

And among the desert people around you are hypocrites, as well as some from among the people of Medina. They persist in hypocrisy. You do not know them. We shall punish them twice; then they will be handed over to terrible torment. (9:101)

To safeguard Islam against the hypocrites was the most difficult task for the Prophet and his followers, since the hypocrites had infiltrated the community and pretended to be faithful to the Prophet without being clearly identifiable. Again we read in the Qur’ān:

They swear by God that they are truly of you while they are not of you, but they are a people who are afraid [of you]. (9:56)

The hypocrites had many plans to assassinate the prophet and to start a civil war in Medina.13 They spoke so beguilingly of Muslim concerns and of their sincere love for Muslims that it seemed they should be counted among the devout Companions of the Prophet:

And when you look at them, their bodies please you, and when they speak, you listen to their words … They are the enemies. So beware of them; may God curse them. How are they denying the right path? (63:4)

They even went so far as to build a mosque, known as al-Ḍirār, and invited the Prophet to pray there. God unveiled their intention to the Prophet and asked him not to pray there. In fact, this was the first mosque to be destroyed, not by the enemies of Islam but by the Prophet himself. The Qur’ān says:

Those who set up a mosque for mischief and disunion among believers as an outpost for any one who has warred on God and His messenger, will swear that they have intended but good. God witnesses that they are certainly liars. (9:107)

In addition to difficulties experienced during the lifetime of the Prophet, his devout followers had to endure much greater difficulties after his demise. They had to protect Islam against threats from external enemies such as the Byzantines as well as those posed by internal enemies. The latter included the hypocrites who had never believed in the Prophet and his message and others who had believed, but did not remain on the right path. This was something that the Qur’ān had warned of:

Muḥammad is not the father of any of your men, but he is the messenger of God and the Seal of the Prophets. If he dies or gets killed will you turn back on your heels? (3:144)

Many wars and disputes took place after the demise of the Prophet, in which at least one party must have been wrong and acted against the interests of Islam and the values that the Prophet called for. Bukhārī, Muslim, Ibn Mājah, Ahmad b. Ḥanbal and others have narrated that the Prophet said:

I will be there at the Fountain of Kawthar before you, and I will have to contend for some people, but I will have to yield. I will be saying: ‘My Lord, they are my Companions, they are my Companions’, and it will be said: ‘You do not know what innovations they made after you.’14

Bukhārī also narrates that the Prophet said in the company of his Companions:

I will be at the Fountain waiting for those who will be coming to me from among you. By God, some people will be prevented from coming to me, and I will say: ‘My Lord, they are my followers and the people of my Ummah’. And God will say: ‘You do not know what they did after you; they have been constantly turning back on their heels.’15

Despite all the difficulties, thanks to God and the guidance of the Prophet, sincere Muslims have faced no ambiguity in identifying the right path since his demise. The Prophet instructed them to adhere to the Qur’ān and his Household, ‘two precious things that will never separate until they meet each other at the Fountain of Kawthar’ with the Prophet. We will end this discussion with a supplication from Imām ‘Ali b. Ḥusayn.’

O God, bless Muḥammad,
entrusted by Thee with Thy revelation,
distinguished by Thee among Thy creatures,
devoted to Thee among Thy servants, the Imām of mercy,
the leader of good,
the key to blessing,
who wearied his soul for Thy affairs,
exposed his body to detested things for Thy sake,
showed open enmity towards his next of kin by summoning to Thee,
fought against his family for Thy good pleasure,
cut the ties of the womb in giving life to Thy religion,
sent far those close because of their denial,
brought near those far because of their response to Thee,
showed friendship to the most distant for Thy sake,
displayed enmity towards the nearest for Thy sake,
made his soul persevere in delivering Thy message,
tired it in summoning to Thy creed,
busied it in counselling those worthy of Thy summons,
migrated to the land of exile and the place of remoteness from
the home of his saddlebags,
the walkway of his feet,
the ground of his birth
and the intimate abode of his soul,
desiring to exalt Thy religion
and seeking help
against those who disbelieved in Thee.16

Divine Justice

All Muslims believe that God is just (‘ādil), in that He never commits any injustice towards His servants and never oppresses anyone. This truth is clearly expressed in the Qur’ān:

God is not in the least unjust to the servants. (3:182 and 8:51 and 22:10)

Your Lord is not in the least unjust to the servants. (41:46)

I am not in the least unjust to the servants. (50:29)

Surely God does not do injustice to the weight of an atom. (4:40)

Surely God does not do any injustice to men, but men are unjust to themselves. (10:44)

In 95:8, the Qur’ān says: ‘Is not God the most conclusive of all judges?’ Again in 21:47, ‘And we have provided a just balance for the Day of Judgement. No soul shall be dealt with unjustly in any way. [Any good deed or evil deed] though it be as small as a grain of the mustard seed, will be brought forth by Us [in testimony]. We suffice as the best of reckoners.’17

In addition to the importance given to divine justice in the Qur’ān and the ḥadīths, there is a contingent, historical reason for the emphasis placed on this doctrine by the Shī‘a. The Ash‘arites, a group of Sunni theologians, have asserted that there is no objective criterion for distinguishing morally right and wrong acts. Good is what God does or commands, so whatever God does or commands is good and just by definition. They believe that if God had asked us to tell lies, telling lies would have become good, and if God were to send pious people to hell, that would be just. They believe of course that God never does such acts, not because they are wrong in themselves, but because He Himself has said that those acts are wrong. Ash‘arites also believe that human beings do not have free will and that it is God who creates their acts without their having any role except the ‘acquisition’ of those acts; men are but receptacles for divine acts.

The Shī‘a and some other Sunni theologians such as the Mu‘tazilites, believe that good and bad or right and wrong are objective, and that there are rational criteria for moral judgements. In other words, they believe in intrinsic good and intrinsic evil. There is a real and objective difference between, say, justice and oppression, and it is not arbitrarily that God has commanded us to be just and not to oppress anyone, even our enemies. The Mu‘tazilites believe further that human beings are free and responsible for their acts by way of tafwīḍ, i.e. God has assigned to humans His authority over their volitional acts so that they have complete control over them. The Shī‘a, by contrast, while rejecting determinism (jabr) as contrary to divine justice and affirming that human beings are free, also believe human freedom to be limited, for God retains authority over their acts. This teaching is expressed in the well-known formulation of Imām Ja‘far al-Ṣādiq:

There is no compulsion (jabr), nor complete delegation of power (tafwīḍ); the truth lies between these two.

Because of the ultimate importance of this subject for any value system, the Shī‘a have always laid stress on divine justice and have frequently included it, together with the unity of God, prophethood, the Imāmate and resurrection, among the five principles of their school of thought (Uṣūl al-Madhhab). By contrast, the unity of God, prophethood and resurrection count as the three principles of religion (Uṣūl al-Dīn), for they are shared by all Muslims.

This emphasis on divine justice has influenced not only the theoretical aspect of Shī‘ism, for the Shī‘a regard justice as such so fundamental an aspect of Islam that they have often called for its implementation in society. Shī‘a movements throughout history have frequently been characterized by a call for justice. We will discuss this issue further when reviewing the distinctive characteristics of Shī‘i Islam.

The Imāmate

The Shī‘a believe in the institution of the Imāmate as a continuation of prophethood. In Arabic the term ‘Imām’ has the general meaning of ‘leader’, irrespective of his personal characteristics and the extent of his leadership, which may range from the congregation of a mosque to a whole nation. In Shī‘i usage, however, the term acquires a specialized sense as the person placed in charge of all the political and religious affairs of the Islamic nation. More precisely, the Imām is a person appointed by God and nominated first by the Prophet and then by each succeeding Imām, through explicit designation (naṣṣ), to lead the Muslim community, to interpret and safeguard both religion and law (sharī‘ah) and to guide the community in all its concerns. The Imām is both the representative of God on earth (khalīfat-ul-lāh) and the successor of the Prophet. He must be sinless and possess divinely bestowed knowledge of both the exoteric and the esoteric meanings of the Qur’ān.

The Twelver Shī‘a who constitute the overwhelming majority of Shī‘a Muslims believe that the Prophet was succeeded by twelve Imāms. These are:

1. Imām ‘Ali b. Abī Ṭālib Died 40/659
2. Imām Ḥasan b. ‘Ali Died 50/669
3. Imām Ḥusayn b. ‘Ali Died 61/680
4. Imām ‘Ali b. Ḥusayn, al-Sajjād Died 95/712
5. Imām Muḥammad b. ‘Ali, al-Bāqir Died 114/732
6. Imām Ja‘far b. Muḥammad, al-Ṣādiq Died 148/765
7. Imām Mūsā b. Ja‘far, al-Kāẓim Died 183/799
8. Imām ‘Ali b. Mūsā, al-Riḍā Died 203/817
9. Imām Muḥammad b. ‘Ali, al-Jawād Died 220/835
10. Imām ‘Ali b. Muḥammad, al-Hādī Died 254/868
11. Imām Ḥasan b. ‘Ali, al-‘Askarī Died 260/872
12. Imām Muḥammad b. Ḥasan, al-Mahdī Born 256/868

On the death of his father in 260 AH, al-Mahdi, the Twelfth Imām, went into occultation (ghaybah), appearing only to a few leading Shī‘a. We will examine the doctrines concerning him later.

The Sunni View

Sunni Muslims use the term ‘Imām’ in certain contexts as equivalent to the term ‘Caliph’ (khalīfah), the Arabic word for ‘successor’. ‘Caliph’ was used as a title for whoever assumed power and ruled the Islamic state after the demise of the Prophet Muḥammad. A Caliph may be elected, nominated by his predecessor or selected by a committee, and he may even acquire power through military force. A Caliph need not be sinless, neither does he need to be superior to others in qualities such as faith or knowledge.

It will be appropriate to refer here to a set of traditions in which the Prophet mentions that there will be twelve leaders after him. For example, Bukhārī reports that the Prophet said: ‘There will be twelve leaders after me.’18 Then the narrator remarks that the Prophet said something that he could not hear. He asked his father, who was also present at the time, to tell him what the Prophet had said. His father told him that the Prophet had said: ‘All these twelve leaders will be from the tribe of Quraysh.’ 19,20 Muslim also reports this tradition, saying that the narrator of this tradition went with his father to the place where the Prophet was, and the Prophet said: ‘This religion will not end until there have been twelve successors.’21 Then the narrator says: ‘The Prophet said something I did not understand and I asked my father. He told me that the Prophet had said: “They are all from Quraysh.”’22

In another tradition, Muslim reports that the Prophet said: ‘People’s affairs will be properly conducted as long as twelve men will lead them.’23 In yet another tradition he said: ‘This religion will be exalted as long as there are twelve successors’.24 It is interesting that some versions of the ḥadīth imply that the existence of these twelve will end with that of the world and of Islam. For example, the Prophet said: ‘This religion [Islam)] will exist as long as there exist twelve successors from the Quraysh.’25 The meaning seems to be that twelve successors will come after the Prophet and their total lifespans will extend down to the end of time.

This set of traditions raises a number of questions. Who are these twelve people? Who are the successors of the Prophet? How can the lifespans of twelve people extend to the end of time? Who are the sources of exaltation for Islam? And who are the twelve successors all from Quraysh? The Shī‘a believe that the answer to all these questions lies in identifying the twelve people mentioned in the traditions as the twelve Imāms. Some non-Shī‘a scholars have gone to great lengths to draw up a different list of twelve named individuals. Some wanted to include all Caliphs starting with Abū Bakr, but when they came to Yazīd b. Mu‘āwīya, they were obliged to exclude him, for he was the one who killed the grandson of the Prophet and many of his relatives and Companions of the Prophet in 61 AH and assaulted Medina in 62 AH.26 Another problem they encounter is that when they reach the twelfth candidate on their list, they see there is no great difference between him and a potential thirteenth successor, possessing the same attributes as his predecessors. Efforts of this type have not yielded any satisfactory result.

Infallibility

Muslims typically believe that the prophets were infallible (ma‘ṣūm) in the affairs relevant to their mission.27 There have, however, been differences of opinion among the various sects of Islam on the extent and duration of the required infallibility. The Shī‘a believe that the prophets never committed sins, major or minor, before or after the beginning of their prophethood, intentionally or unintentionally, whether in matters relevant to their mission or in their personal life. Sunni Muslims generally believe that the prophets were infallible only during their prophethood, and some restrict their infallibility to matters directly pertinent to their message. Ash‘arites, for example, confine infallibility to intentional sins, whether minor or major, so that the prophets might have committed some sins unintentionally. The Mu‘tazilites believe that the prophets were infallible in relation to major sins, intentionally or unintentionally, but that they might have committed minor sins. Al-Baghdādī in his Al-Farq bayn al-Firaq describes the creed of Sunni Muslims as follows: ‘They believe in the infallibility of the prophets in relation to sins. They have construed what is narrated about their lapses as having occurred before their prophethood.’28 ‘Allāmah al-Ḥillī in his Al-Bāb al-Ḥādī ‘Ashar describes the creed of the Shī‘a as follows: ‘Truly, the prophets are infallible from the beginning of their lives till the end, because the hearts of the people do not tend to obey those whom they have witnessed previously committing different types of minor and major sins and hateful or unpleasant acts.’29

Muslims have argued for the infallibility of the prophets in different ways. The following verse is often adduced: ‘And when his Lord tried Abraham with certain words, he fulfilled them. He said: “Surely I will make you an Imām of men.” Abraham said: “And of my offspring?” “My covenant does not include the unjust,” said He.’ (2:124) Although the beginning of the verse concerns the position of Imāmate, the concluding phrase suggests a general rule: to be qualified for any divinely bestowed position one must possess an extraordinary degree of piety and purity of soul. According to the Qur’ān, any breach of religious laws is considered an act of oppression (ẓulm). Those who committed sins, especially shirk (associating someone with God), the most grievous of all sins, could not therefore have been chosen by God to become a prophet. Those who do not believe in the necessity of infallibility before the onset of prophethood think that it does no harm if a future prophet commits some sin or other, on condition that such conduct then cease.

There are also theological arguments for infallibility, such as that found in the following passage by M. R. Muzaffar:

The reason for the infallibility of a prophet is that if he commits a sin or mistake, or is forgetful or something similar, we have to choose between two alternatives: either we obey his sins and mistakes, in which case, in the view of Islam, we do wrong, or we must not obey his sins and mistakes, which too is wrong, because this is contrary to the idea of prophethood where obedience is necessary; besides, if everything he says or does has the possibility of being either right or wrong, then it is impossible for us to follow him. The result is that the benefit of his mission is lost; it becomes unnecessary, and the prophet becomes like ordinary people whose acts and speech do not have the excellent worth that we seek, with the result that there will be no obedience and his actions will be unreliable.30

It has to be noted that the arguments for the infallibility of the prophets differ in their scope and implications, some implying their infallibility throughout their lives and others focusing on their lives after the beginning of prophethood. In what follows, we will try to single out and discuss different aspects of infallibility.

  1. Infallibility after the start of prophethood in preaching and delivering the divine message. This is something that all Muslims agree on, for if a prophet makes mistakes or disregards his duties in preaching the divine message, the benefit of delivering the message would be lost and, moreover, people would be misguided by following him.31

  2. Infallibility after the start of prophethood in personal life, as for example in dealings with family, friends, neighbours and so on. Some Muslims regard this type of infallibility as unnecessary with respect to minor sins or those unintentionally committed. The Shī‘a and some others believe, however, that this dimension of infallibility is also necessary, because prophets are not simply tutors or propagators; they are designated by God to embody a path of perfection and piety in all their sayings and the entirety of their conduct. People need, moreover, practical examples in addition to theoretical lessons. A prophet who did not embody in his personal life the values that he was preaching would not have fulfilled his mission. He would also weaken his message, because any awareness of shortcomings in his personal life would incline people to think that he himself was not fully convinced of his own mission.

    What of unintentional sins or mistakes for which one is usually not held responsible? It seems clear that even in this case many of the same problems would arise. First, people would not always be able to distinguish among intentional and unintentional acts. For example, if they see that a prophet is breaking a law, disregarding someone’s rights or is not performing a religious act, it would not always be possible for them to decide whether or not he is mindful of his actions. People who are looking for an excuse to justify their own faults would be particularly prone to fasten on such incidents. Moreover, even if we suppose that people were able in practice to distinguish among intentional and unintentional sins, it is only to be expected that as soon as they saw their prophet to be fallible and to have his own failures and shortcomings, they would lose their trust in him with respect to his preaching and message. If a prophet forgot an appointment or forgot to say his prayer, how could people be certain that he had not made mistakes or forgotten something in communicating the revealed message? How could people be prepared to entrust their lives and souls to such a person?

    It must be admitted, as a matter of reality, that the ordinary believers who constitute the majority of those addressed by the Prophetic mission would not be able to draw the fine distinctions that some theologians suggest. Indeed, many of those same theologians would not be able to draw similar distinctions in their own personal experience, such as the distinction between the truth of what is said and the moral status or intention of the speaker. Most people, even if they are themselves Muslim, would not pay any heed to a skilful and learned preacher who is known to commit immoral acts in his personal life. It follows then that unbelievers who have led a self-indulgent life unchecked by any belief in God would be still less inclined to follow a person of dubious character calling on them to change their life totally, commit themselves to new values and be prepared to undergo sacrifices.

    There have, of course, been many pious personalities in the Muslim world, especially among the scholars, who have led lives of exemplary purity. The difference between such people and the prophets is that the prophets’ infallibility is all-inclusive, and that unlike the prophets they are not safeguarded from the possibility of sinning.

  3. Infallibility before prophethood. In light of the foregoing, it can be understood why the Shī‘a believe that the prophets must be infallible before their prophethood as well. Although prophets were human beings who lived with others and shared their human concerns, they were always outstanding figures respected by the people and admired even by their enemies. For example, the Prophet of Islam was known as al-Amīn (‘the trustworthy one’) in the pagan society of Mecca, and was a paragon of virtue from his childhood till his death. In fact, the virtuous life of a prophet before the beginning of his prophethood and before people come to believe in him is in a sense more important, for the most challenging time comes when the prophet wants to convince people of his word; if he can be trusted in all other matters, he can credibly ask for their trust with respect to God and religion.

    Another reason for the belief in infallibility, applicable both to the period preceding the onset of prophethood and that following it, is that God’s choice is not arbitrary. To be addressed by God, to receive revelation and direct and immediate communication from the unseen, is so extraordinarily demanding an experience that it can be borne only by one possessing high spiritual capacity. The Qur’ān says: ‘Surely, we will reveal to you some heavy words.’ (73:5) None can reach the requisite position if he is tainted by false belief or sin, for sins are harmful to the spirit and to the purity of the soul, even if committed unintentionally. A person committing a sin by mistake may be excused, as for example a person who drinks wine not realizing it be such, but the sin nonetheless has its natural effect upon the soul.

    The Shī‘a thus hold prophethood in very high esteem. They believe that the prophets were pious and pure throughout their lives and that they were immune from committing sins or other acts deleterious to their spirit or to the trust of the people in them.

What is the True Nature of Infallibility?

On the true nature of infallibility, Naṣīr al-Dīn al-Ṭūsī, a great Shī‘a scholar who was able to reconcile theology (kalām) with philosophy, says:

Infallibility is when the servant [of God] is able to perform sins, but he does not wish to do so at all. And this lack of will [for sins] or the existence of something that prevents him from that is a divine grace for him. So he does not disobey God, not because he is unable to do so, but because he does not will to do so, or because there is something that overrides his will. Thus, considering his power (and free will) it is possible for him to perform sins, but considering his lack of will or the existence of the overriding obstacle, it is impossible.32

Al-Ījī, a well-known Ash‘arite theologian, explains infallibility as follows:

For us [the Ash‘arites] infallibility is that God does not create in them [the prophets] any sin. For the philosophers, it is a character (al-malakah) that prevents one from sinning and is caused by knowing the wretchedness of sins and the merits of obedience to God and is strengthened by the repetition of revelation of commands and prohibitions.33

Shī‘a theologians and philosophers believe that since prophets are human and must be examples for human beings, in essence it is possible for them to commit sins. The prophets are not like angels who cannot commit sins. However, the prophets are so pure in their souls, deep in their understandings, insightful in their conduct and mindful of God that neither do they desire to perform immoral acts, nor does it occur to them to commit such gross deeds. Indeed, most of us are infallible in respect to certain acts, such as eating mud, beating our parents, going naked in public or throwing ourselves from the roof. Although we are able to do all the above acts, we have a type of immunity in respect of them, such that it would not even occur to us to do such ridiculous things. This is caused by our self-respect and care, on the one hand, and our clear understanding of the harmfulness and wrongness of those acts, on the other.

The prophets possessed this immunity with respect to all types of sins. They were not even content with their exemption from conventional sins. To them, failure to remember God for a while, even while performing some social duties, was not acceptable. They regarded many acts that are considered as acts of piety and worship for ordinary human beings as insufficient and they asked God for forgiveness when they performed them. It must therefore be noted that what the prophets considered as sins for themselves and for which they asked forgiveness were not sins in the ordinary sense.

Basing themselves on the arguments mentioned above and the clear teachings of the Household of the Prophet, the Shī‘a do not endorse any report or narration that suggests the performance of sins or any act by prophets that may make people despise them or distance themselves from them. Shī‘a scholars have studied all the verses of the Qur’ān that are sometimes taken to suggest otherwise and have shown that the real interpretation of those verses does not contradict the above idea.34

The Shī‘a have the highest estimation for the Prophet Muḥammad and see in all aspects of his character and conduct the most perfect model.

Surely you have in the Messenger of God an excellent exemplar … (33:21)

They also believe that the Imāms must enjoy the same quality of infallibility. The reason for this is that the Imāmate is also a divinely bestowed position that requires a high degree of purity and spirituality. No one can reach this position without being completely free from sins and immoral acts. As mentioned above, even many things that are allowed for ordinary people must be eschewed by such people, such as speaking too much, or eating or sleeping more than is necessary. And since people must completely trust them, they must be free from mistakes as well.

In addition to the verse (2:124) that we discussed above, in respect to the Household of the Prophet the Qur’ān says:

… God merely wants to remove any uncleanliness from you [since you are] People of the [Prophet’s] House, and to cleanse you thoroughly. (33:33)

The Qur’ān clearly asserts that the Household of the Prophet are protected and purified from all types of impurity including sins and bad character. They are free from whatever is disliked by human beings. Freedom from sin is certainly what is meant by the above verse; otherwise there would be no difference between them and other believers who safeguard themselves, as the Qur’ān says:

Surely the pious, when a visitation from Satan afflicts them they become mindful, then lo they see aright. (7:201)

This verse shows that the pious not only do not deliberately make mistakes but are also not deceived by Satan.

The Doctrine of al-Mahdi

The belief in a saviour figure to come at the end of time is shared by most religions. In Islam, this figure is known as al-Mahdi (the Guided One); he will arise with divine blessing and fill the earth with justice after it was previously filled with injustice and oppression.35 Summarizing the beliefs of all Muslims about al-Mahdi (AS), Ibn Khaldūn (d. 808/1406) writes:

Let it be known that it is a narrated event by all Muslims in every era, that at the end of time a man from the family of the Prophet will, without fail, make his appearance and will strengthen Islam and spread justice; Muslims will follow him and he will gain domination over the Muslim realm. He will be called al-Mahdi.36

The idea of a saviour who will inaugurate a period of justice at the end of time is indicated in many verses of the Qur’ān and ḥadīths. For example, we read in the Qur’ān:

God has promised to appoint those of you who believe and perform honourable deeds as [His] representatives on earth, just as He made those before them into [such] overlords, and to establish their religion for them which He has approved for them, and to change their fear into confidence. They serve Me [Alone] and do not associate anything else with me … (24:55)

We have written in the Psalms the Reminder: ‘My honourable servants shall inherit the earth’. (21:105)

Yet We wanted to endow those who were considered inferior on earth, and make them into leaders and make them [Our] heirs. (28:5)

The following are a few examples of ḥadīths concerning the Mahdi narrated in both Sunni and Shī‘i sources:

  1. The Prophet said:

    Even if the entire duration of the world’s existence has already been exhausted and only one day is left (before the Day of Judgement), God will expand that day to such a length of time as to accommodate the kingdom of a person from my Household who will be called by my name.’37

  2. The Prophet also said:

    Al-Mahdi is one of us, a member of the Household (Ahl al-Bayt). God will prepare for him [his affairs] in one night.38

  3. Again, he said:

    Al-Mahdi will be of my family, of the descendants of Fāṭima.39

  4. It is also narrated from Jābir b. ‘Abdillāh al-Anṣārī that he heard the Messenger of God saying:

    A group of my nation will fight for the truth until near the Day of Judgement when Jesus, son of Mary, will descend, and their leader will ask him to lead the prayer, but Jesus will decline, saying: ‘No, verily, among you God has made leaders for others in order to honour this nation.’40

It is clear that al-Mahdi is different from Jesus, although they will both come at the same time. Let us note that in the Qur’ān and other Islamic sources al-Masīḥ, meaning ‘wiped clean, purified’, is a title for Jesus. This title bears obvious similarity to the English term ‘messiah’, applied by Christians to Jesus. However, the word ‘messiah’ may also be used to refer to the expected king and deliverer of the Jews, or metaphorically to the professed or accepted leader of some group or cause. ‘Messiah’ has accordingly been used in some English-language writings to refer also to the Mahdi of Islamic belief, but this should not be taken to mean that al-Mahdi is al-Masīḥ, a term reserved in Islamic usage for Jesus.

Al-Mahdi will have a universal mission, departing from the Arab lands. His name will be the same as that of the Prophet Muḥammad and he will be from the progeny of Fāṭima. The Shī‘a believe that he is the son of Imām Ḥasan al-‘Askarī. He was born in 255 (AH). He entered occultation in the year 260 AH. He is still alive and preserved by God in occultation until conditions become ripe for his reappearance. The same is believed by some Sunni scholars, but others among them believe that he has not yet been born. Sayyid Muḥsin al-Amīn in his A‘yān al-Shī‘ah has named thirteen examples of those Sunni scholars who have asserted that al-Mahdi is the son of Imām Ḥasan and has already been born, including Muḥammad b. Yusuf al-Kanjī al-Shāfi‘ī in his Al-Bayān fī Akhbār Ṣāḥib al-Zamān and Kifāyat al-Ṭālib fī Manāqib ‘Alī b. Abī Ṭālib; Nūr al-Dīn ‘Ali b. Muḥammad al-Mālikī in his Al-Fuṣūl al-Muhimmah fī Ma‘rifat al-A’immah and Ibn al-Jawzī in his well-known Tadhkirat al-Khawāṣṣ.

In conclusion, we may cite the fatwā issued in Mecca by the Muslim World League (Rābiṭat al-‘Ālam al-Islāmī) on October 11, 1976/ Shawwāl 23, 1396. It states that more than twenty companions narrated traditions concerning al-Mahdi and gives a list of scholars of ḥadīth who have transmitted these narrations, as well as those scholars who have written books on al-Mahdi. Its text reads in part:

The memorizers (Ḥuffāẓ) and scholars of ḥadīth have verified that there are authentic (ṣaḥīḥ) and acceptable (ḥasan) reports among the traditions related to al-Mahdi. The majority of these traditions are related through numerous authorities (mutawātir). There is no doubt that the status of those reports is ṣaḥīḥ and mutawātir, that the belief in al-Mahdi is obligatory, and that it is one of the beliefs of Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jamā‘ah. Only those ignorant of the Sunnah and innovators in the doctrine deny it.41