TWO
Sources of Shī‘i Thought
Before studying Shī‘a doctrines or practices, it is necessary to identify the sources on which the Shī‘a rely for understanding Islam and the methodology they adopt in using those sources. In what follows, we will study the four sources of Shī‘i thought as they relate to jurisprudence in particular: the Glorious Qur’ān, the Sunnah, reason and consensus.
The Glorious Qur’ān
The Qur’ān is, of course, the most important source for all Muslims, including the Shī‘a. The Qur’ān therefore acts as an instrument of unity among all Muslims. Regardless of their different sectarian and cultural backgrounds, all Muslims refer to the same book as the divine guide to govern their life. As at any other time in history, today throughout the Muslim world there exists only one Qur’ān without any addition or alterations. A typical Shī‘a standpoint towards the Qur’ān can be found in the following passage:
We believe that the Qur’ān was divinely inspired, and revealed by Allah on the tongue of His honourable Prophet, making clear everything, an everlasting miracle. Man is unable to write anything like it because of its eloquence, clarity, truth and knowledge, and no alteration can be made to it. The Qur’ān we have now is exactly what was sent to the Prophet, and anyone who claims otherwise is an evildoer, a mere sophist or else a person in error, and all of them have gone astray, because it is the speech of Allah, and ‘Falsehood cannot come at it from before it or from behind.’ (41:42)
… We also believe that we must respect and give dignity to the Glorious Qur’ān, and this both in word and in deed. Therefore, it must not be defiled intentionally, not even one of its letters, and it must not be touched by one who is not ṭāhir [pure]. It is said in the Qur’ān that ‘None can touch it save the purified.’ (56:79) (Muzaffar, p. 26)
Shī‘a Deny Any Alteration in the Qur’ān
As mentioned above, the Shī‘a deny any alteration in the Qur’ān and believe that the Qur’ān available today is the same one as was revealed to the Prophet Muḥammad. The Qur’ān is complete. However, some people who were not familiar with Shī‘i Islam and had no close contact with Shī‘a communities claimed that the Shī‘a believe that the Qur’ān had been altered and some parts of it had been deleted. The basis for this accusation can be nothing more than the existence of some ḥadīths in Shī‘a collections that have been taken to suggest the occurrence of alteration in the Qur’ān. Neither the overwhelming majority of reputable Shī‘a scholars nor of ordinary believers have ever held such a belief. Indeed, this charge is so odd that it does not deserve to be taken seriously and, when it is made, it is usually done for polemical and hostile purposes.
No one has ever seen a copy of the Qur’ān different from the standard one in any part of the Islamic world. There are manuscripts of the Qur’ān available today that go back to the time of Shī‘a Imāms and they are exactly the same as the current ones. In addition to the copies kept in the museums of Iran, Pakistan, Iraq and other parts of the world, copies of great historical value kept in the Museum of the Qur’ān in the city of Mashhad are particularly noteworthy.1
The Glorious Qur’ān explicitly says that God Himself preserves the Qur’ān from alteration and textual mutilation:
Surely We have revealed the Reminder and We will most surely be its preserver. (15:9)2
Regarding this verse, ‘Allāmah Ṭabāṭabā’ī in his renowned Al-Mīzān fī Tafsīr al-Qur’ān, one of the greatest commentaries on the Qur’ān, states:
[T]he Qur’ān is a living and eternal Reminder, which will never die and fall into oblivion. It is immune from any addition and loss. It is immune from and secure against any alterations in form and style that could affect its character and role, that is, as ‘the Reminder of Allah which expresses divine truth and knowledge’. For this reason, the aforesaid verse indicates that the Divine Book has always been and will continue to be guarded against any mutilation and alteration.
In what follows, we will study some of the statements of Shī‘a scholars in different ages regarding this matter. And since the reason for charging the Shī‘a with a belief that the Qur’ān has been altered is the existence of few ḥadīths in some Shī‘a books that have been taken to suggest alteration, we will also refer to aspects of Shī‘a methodology in ḥadīth studies in order to understand the Shī‘i approach to ḥadīths in general and the ḥadīths at issue in particular. It has to be noted that similar or even stronger ḥadīths exist in non-Shī‘a sources. However, the Shī‘a have never accused their Sunni brothers of believing in the alteration of the Qur’ān, since when attributing certain beliefs to any group one has to refer to the statements made by one’s own authorities, and not to isolated statements that they themselves do not accept or interpret in a way different from what outsiders may claim.
Statements of Shī‘a Scholars About the Qur’ān
The best way to understand Shī‘a views concerning the Qur’ān is to refer to the statements of their great scholars. Examples now follow.
1. Shaykh al-Ṣadūq (d. 381), known as ‘Shaykh al-muḥaddithīn’ (the master of traditionists), in his al-I‘tiqādāt al-Imāmīyah (Shī‘ite Creed) says:
Our belief is that the Qur’ān that Allah revealed to His Prophet Muḥammad is [the same as] the one between the two covers (daffatayn). And it is the one that is in the hands of the people, and is not greater in extent than that. The number of chapters as generally accepted is one hundred and fourteen … And he who asserts that we say that it is greater in extent than that, is a liar.3
2. Sayyid al-Murtaḍā (d. 436/1044) states:
Knowledge and certainty about the validity of the narration of the Holy Qur’ān are like knowledge and certainty about the existence of countries, cities, famous historical events … This is because the specific regard for and attention given to the Holy Qur’ān and the strong motive for recording and guarding its text were much stronger than the care and attention given to the above-cited items … During the time of the Messenger of Allah (S), the Holy Qur’ān had been a compiled collection exactly as it is now. The Holy Prophet (S) had even charged a group of his Companions with the responsibility of memorizing and safeguarding the Holy Qur’ān. At that time, it was customary for the people to recite the Holy Qur’ān before the Holy Prophet (S) to ensure the accuracy of the text. The Holy Prophet (S), too, listened to their recitation. A group of the Companions, such as ‘Abdullāh b. Mas‘ūd, Ubayy b. Ka‘b and others, read the whole text of the Holy Qur’ān several times in the presence of the Holy Prophet (S).
With a little attention, one comes to realize that all these matters indicate that the Holy Qur’ān has been a compiled collection. No one takes into account the opponents of this belief, be they from Imāmīyah or Ḥashwīyah, for their view is derived from a group of the people of ḥadīth who narrated weak ḥadīth on the subject, thinking that they had related reliable and valid ḥadīth. However, such weak ḥadīths have no power to challenge something based on definitive knowledge and certainty.4
3. Muḥammad b. al-Ḥasan al-Ṭūsī (d. 460/1067), known as Shaykh al-Tā’ifah, the master of Shī‘a sect, states:
The remarks about addition and loss in the Qur’ānic text are not noteworthy; there is a consensus among the ‘Ulamā regarding the invalidity of this matter.
4. Shaykh al-Ṭabarsī (d. 548/1153 or 538/1143?) in his renowned Qur’ānic Exegesis, Majma‘ al-Bayān, says:
There is a consensus and unanimity among the Muslims that no additions have been made to the Holy Qur’ān. But with regard to omissions from the text of the Holy Qur’ān, a group of Imāmīyah and a group of Ḥashwīyah (who are Sunnis) have said that there are alterations and deficiencies in the Holy Qur’ān, but the true belief accepted by the Imāmīyah holds otherwise.
5. Sayyid b. Ṭāwūs (d. 664/1265) in his Sa‘d al-Su‘ūd says:
In truth, the Imāmīyah believe in the absence of alteration to the Holy Qur’ān.5
Shī‘a Ḥadīths About the Qur’ān
Here we refer only to aspects of Shī‘a methodology in ḥadīth studies that bear on the subject at hand and ones similar to it. First of all it should be made clear that no collection of ḥadīth is regarded by the Shī‘a to be authentic (ṣaḥīḥ) in its entirety. However great, valuable and generally accurate a collection of ḥadīth may be, Shī‘a scholars do not automatically assume its contents to be authentic. Every single ḥadīth mentioned in any collection of ḥadīth has to be investigated separately. To be able to use a given ḥadīth as his reference, a Shī‘a scholar needs first to consider at least three issues:
1. The means through which he has received the book containing that ḥadīth. For example, if a ḥadīth is mentioned in Al-Kāfī, which was written in the fourth century, the researcher has to make sure that the copy of Al-Kāfī that he has is identical to the author’s copy. For this purpose Shī‘a scholars of ḥadīth generation after generation checked their copies of those books with their masters, ḥadīth by ḥadīth, and having completed this task they would get permission from their masters to narrate from the author of the original book.
2. Having made sure that the book he has in his hands is identical to the original book, a scholar needs to investigate the chain of narrators through which he has received the saying from the Prophet or the Imāms. For this purpose, he has to make sure that nothing is missing in the chain of narrators, that all the people occurring in the chain are accurately identified and all those identified as narrators are trustworthy and reliable. If only one person, say, out of ten is missing, is unknown or is known to be a liar, the whole chain becomes invalid.
3. When the first two tasks are completed, the scholar of ḥadīth must next make several general investigations about the content of the ḥadīth to enable him to use that ḥadīth as his reference. The first is to check whether the ḥadīth is compatible with the Qur’ān or not. Without any doubt, all Shī‘a agree that whatever ḥadīth contradicts the Qur’ān or is against Qur’ānic teachings has to be rejected, even if all the narrators happen to be trustworthy. There are very clear instructions from the Imāms of the Household of the Prophet in this regard. For example, Ibn Abī Ya‘fūr says:
I asked Abū Abdillāh (Imām Ṣādiq) about the different traditions narrated by those whom we trust and also by those whom we don't. Hearing this, the Imām replied: ‘Whenever you receive a tradition which is borne out by any verse from the Book of God or by an [established] saying of the Prophet, then accept it. Otherwise, the tradition is to be left only for the one who has brought it to you.’6
No one can say that, because so-and-so was a very great scholar, anything that is mentioned in his book is correct. Therefore, the Shī‘a do not believe in any Ṣaḥīḥ (all-authentic) collection of ḥadīth, in contrast to the belief of the Sunnis concerning the collections of Bukhārī and Muslim. Despite their unquestioned high status for all Shī‘a scholars, the Four Books of ḥadīth (al-Kutub al-Arba‘ah), i.e. Al-Kāfī, Man lā Yaḥḍuruhū al-Faqīh, Tahdhīb al-Aḥkām and Al-Istibṣār, are not regarded either by their compilers or by other scholars as authentic in their entirety.7 For the Shī‘a, the Qur’ān is the only all-authentic book, with which every other source has to be in accordance. This very point is mentioned in the preface to Uṣūl al-Kāfī by Shaykh al-Kulaynī himself:
Brother, may Allah lead you to the right path. You should know that it is not for anyone to distinguish the truth in the conflicting narrations attributed to the ‘Ulamā [i.e. Imāms], peace be upon them, except through the standards that have been declared by al-‘Ālim [i.e. the Imām], peace be upon him: ‘Test the [conflicting] traditions by the Book of Allah, and that which agrees with it, take it, and that which disagrees with it, reject it.’
By contrast, Sunni Muslims believe that there are six Ṣaḥīḥs (al-Ṣiḥāḥ al-Sittah), which are believed to be all-authentic collections of ḥadīths.
Muṣḥaf of Fāṭima
Another subject that is sometimes misunderstood is the subject of the Muṣḥaf of Fāṭima, the daughter of the Prophet. According to some Shī‘a traditions, there is a book bearing this name, kept by the Imāms of the Household of the Prophet. In Arabic, the term Muṣḥaf means ‘book’ or ‘collection of pages,’ being derived from ṣafḥah meaning ‘page’. Similar words are ṣuḥuf (like the ṣuḥuf of Abraham and Moses, referred to in the Qur’ān to mean the books they received) and ṣaḥīfah, ‘newspaper’ in modern Arabic. Thus, Muṣḥaf does not necessarily mean the Qur’ān: the word can be applied both to the Qur’ān and to other books. Some people have thought that since the Shī‘a have ḥadīths about the Muṣḥaf of Fāṭima, they believe in another Qur’ān. This misunderstanding is perhaps caused by lack of knowledge of Arabic and Shī‘a traditions.
The Muṣḥaf of Fāṭima is also not something that attempts to rival the Holy Qur’ān. There is a tradition from Imām Ṣādiq, which says that the Muṣḥaf of Fāṭima includes information about future events and contains a list of names of those people who will rule in the future, including the Umayyads, the Abbasids and so on. There is nothing of the Qur’ān in it. Neither is there anything related to the practical laws of Islam.8
According to some traditions, when the Prophet died, Fāṭima was very sad, so the archangel Gabriel used to go and talk to her about future events in order to console her. The information he conveyed to her was then put together in the form of a book and became known as the Muṣḥaf of Fāṭima.
Aware that there is no ground for accusing the Shī‘a of having another Qur’ān, some people adopt the tactic of attacking them by saying that the Shī‘a believe that Fāṭima was a messenger of God. However, as we have just seen, the Muṣḥaf of Fāṭima has nothing to do with prophethood. According to a ḥadīth from Imām Ṣādiq found in Uṣūl al-Kāfī, Fāṭima died 75 days after the demise of the Prophet. She was very sad because of the death of her father, so Gabriel used to come and express his condolences to Fāṭima and speak about the place of the Prophet in Paradise to make Fāṭima rejoice. Gabriel also explained to Fāṭima what would happen to her children. Imām ‘Ali wrote all this down in a collection that later became known as the Muṣḥaf of Fāṭima. It was not a matter of prophethood. All Shī‘a believe that the Prophet Muḥammad was the last prophet, but this does not mean that God could not communicate anything to anyone after his death. According to the Qur’ān, it is quite clear that divine inspiration or communication comes in different forms, some being exclusive to the Prophets and others not. For example, the mother of Moses was inspired by some kind of communication, though there is no claim that she was a prophet. In fact, God may even inspire non-humans, such as the bees:
Your Lord has revealed to the bees to select a place for living from the mountains. (16:68)
This kind of guidance and inspiration is called waḥy, but it was not a matter of prophethood. So the term waḥy generally means ‘inspiration’, whether exclusive to the prophets or more generally. Fāṭima’s access to heavenly information does not therefore mean that she was a prophet. It was an indication of her purity and an endorsement of the great love that the Prophet Muḥammad had shown her. It confirms that whatever the Prophet said about her was correct, for he said: ‘Fāṭima is part of me. What angers her angers me.’9
The Sunnah
After the Glorious Qur’ān, the most important source for understanding Islam and therefore Shī‘i thought is the Sunnah of the Prophet Muḥammad, including his sayings, his deeds and his tacit approval of what was conducted in his presence. The Qur’ān itself clearly gives such a high position to the Prophet, as he is referred to as the one who is responsible for explaining the Qur’ān (16:44) and teaching the Qur’ān and wisdom (62:2). The Prophet is a perfect example for believers (33:21). He never speaks of his own wishes (53:3). Muslims are asked to hold on to whatever he gives them and refrain from whatever he prohibits (59:7).
Awareness of the above verses and many others relating to the status of the Prophet, together with consciousness of his having been a messenger chosen directly by God and addressed by Him, induced in the Shī‘a, together with other Muslims, sincere love for and devotion to the Prophet Muḥammad.
Compilation of Ḥadīths
During the Life of the Prophet
From the very beginning Muslims started writing down traditions of the Seal of the Prophets and transmitting them to those who had not been present when the utterances were made. Collections of Prophetic narrations, known as Ṣaḥīfah, were made by people such as ‘Abdullāh b. ‘Amr b. al-‘Āṣ, Samarah b. Jundab, Sa‘d b. ‘Ubādah and Jābir b. ‘Abdullāh al-Anṣārī. According to a well-known ḥadīth, ‘Abdullāh b. ‘Amr b. al-‘Āṣ used to write down whatever he heard from the Prophet, but then he was prohibited from doing so by the Quraysh. They argued that the Prophet was a human being who speaks when he is angry and when he is happy (meaning that his statements might be influenced by emotion and not fully intentional). ‘Abdullāh therefore stopped writing down ḥadīths until he spoke to the Prophet about what had happened. Then the Prophet pointed to his mouth and said: ‘Do write! I swear by Him Who has my life in His hand that nothing other than the truth has ever come out of it.’10 Imām Ahmad narrates from Abū Hurayrah that the Prophet Muḥammad told his Companions to write his ḥadīth for a person called ‘Abū Shāt’.11 Then Imām Ahmad cites Abū ‘Abd al-Raḥmān to have said that no ḥadīth stronger than this has been narrated to demonstrate the importance of writing down ḥadīths, since it contains an order from the Prophet himself.
This episode shows that some people were not happy with the recording of ḥadīths because they failed to appreciate properly the status of the Prophet Muḥammad. However, Muslims did not listen to their opinions and continued to write down ḥadīths.12
During the Time of the First Caliph
A famous Sunni scholar, Dhahabi, in his book Tadhkirat al-Ḥuffāẓ (A Memorial of the Memorizers), reports that Abū Bakr gathered the people and said: ‘O people! O Companions of the Prophet! You report something from the Prophet, although there is no agreement among you. It is better therefore not to narrate the traditions of the Prophet any more, and if someone asks you about the views of the Prophet in respect of some matters, simply reply that we have the Book of Allah and it is enough for us. It is sufficient: whatever is permitted in the Qur’ān is permitted (ḥalāl) and whatever is forbidden in the Qur’ān is forbidden (ḥarām). Do not go any further. Do not say anything about the views of the Prophet and his traditions.’13
During the Time of the Second Caliph
At this time even more severe decisions were taken against those who wanted to narrate traditions of the Prophet. For example, in a striking story, one of the companions of the Prophet, Qaraẓah b. Ka‘b, says that the second Caliph sent a group of the Anṣār to Kufa and asked him to accompany them.14 The Caliph himself escorted them as far as a place outside Medina called Sirā’ and asked them: ‘Do you know why I escorted you and came with you this distance?’ Qaraẓah says that they replied: ‘Because you wanted to show your respect for Anṣār.’ The second Caliph affirmed that, but added that he had something more to say. He said: ‘You are going to a people whose tongues move with [the recitation of the] Qur’ān like date trees [moving with winds]. When you reach there people will say: “The Companions of Muḥammad have come. The Companions of Muḥammad have come.” They will ask you to narrate ḥadīths. Beware, do not hinder them with ḥadīths of the Prophet and I am your partner (sharīk).’ Thus the second Caliph asked them not to mention ḥadīths, said that he would support them in this and affirmed that he had adopted the same policy himself.
As the second Caliph predicted, when the delegation arrived in Kufa people asked them to narrate ḥadīths of the Prophet, because they like other Muslims had a sincere love of the Prophet and wanted to know and to hear something from the Prophet. They wanted to benefit from the example of the Prophet and his explanation of the Qur’ān. However, Qaraẓah says: ‘I did not mention any ḥadīths.’15
Al-Dārimī reports in his Sunan from Sha‘bī that he accompanied Abdullāh b. ‘Umar (the son of the second Caliph) for a whole year and he did not hear any tradition of the Prophet from him.16 Al-Dārimī also narrates that this continued for a longer period, that is, for two and half years, and that he heard just one ḥadīth from ‘Abdullāh.17 He also narrates from Sa‘d b. Yazīd that he was with Sa‘d b. Abī Waqqāṣ on his journey to Mecca, during his stay in Mecca and on his return journey to Medina, but he did not hear any tradition of the Prophet from him. Still more striking events happened at this time. For example, Dhahabī reports in Tadhkirat al-Ḥuffāẓ that three great companions of the Prophet were imprisoned for narrating Prophetic traditions. One of them was Ibn Mas‘ūd, a well-known scribe (kātib) and reciter of the Qur’ān, who had embraced Islam very early and been tortured by the pagans of Quraysh.18
During the Time of the Third Caliph
The discouraging of ḥadīth narration remained in effect. Interestingly enough, the third Caliph, ‘Uthmān b. ‘Affān, sometimes argued for the necessity of suppressing the traditions of the Prophet by referring to the Sunnah or conduct of the first two Caliphs. For example, he used to say that no one was allowed to mention any tradition that had not been mentioned during the time of Abū Bakr or ‘Umar. Since we know that no one was allowed to narrate any tradition during the time of the first and second Caliphs, this automatically applied to his time too.
What was the reason for attempting to prevent the writing and narrating traditions of the Prophet? The explanation generally given was that if people were allowed to mention traditions of the Prophet it could distract them from paying attention to the Qur’ān.19 If they had been allowed to have two things in parallel, the Qur’ān and the Sunnah, they might devote less attention to the Qur’ān and they might forget it, and this in turn would have made the Qur’ān subject to omissions or alterations.20
However, there was no reason to be concerned for the preservation of the Qur’ān at that time, because in the lifetime of the Prophet there were already many people who had memorized the Qur’ān and numerous written copies of the Qur’ān had been made. We know that the Prophet himself gave instructions to the Muslims about the arrangement of the verses and chapters of the Qur’ān. We also know that the Arabs at that time had powerful memories, so there was no cause for concern that the Qur’ān might be forgotten or altered. It is also not reasonable to imagine that Muslims were so careless or weak that they could not take care of the Qur’ān as well as the sayings of the Prophet at the same time. It is inconceivable that such a nation, numbering many great figures among it and possessing moreover God-given talents of memorizing, should not have been able to deal with two treasures at the same time.
In any case, according to the Shī‘a and later Sunni traditionists (along with later caliphs, from ‘Umar b. ‘Abdul ‘Azīz onwards), this view was not compatible with the clear Qur’ānic instructions to follow the model of Islamic conduct that the Prophet presented in his Sunnah. It cannot be imagined that the founder of a school of thought should present his ideas but that after his death or even earlier people should be told to ignore what he said or did and not mention or record it. Could people have been expected in such a case to understand the teachings of that school, given that it was the result of revelation and people had no immediate and direct access to its source? How could it have been possible to ask people to understand the Qur’ān while neglecting the teachings of the person to whom the Qur’ān was revealed, and who, according to the Qur’ān itself, was charged with teaching and explaining the Qur’ān?
In any event, there are also clear instructions, narrated by both Shī‘a and Sunni scholars, from the Prophet himself on the necessity of transmitting his ḥadīths to others. For example, in the last year of his blessed life and while returning from Mecca in his final pilgrimage, hajjat al-widā‘, in a famous and historic statement, the Prophet said: ‘May God make happy those people who listen to my speech, comprehend it and then transmit it to those who have not heard it.’ There are many people who transmit the knowledge though they themselves may not be knowledgeable, and likewise there are many people who can transmit knowledge to those more knowledgeable than themselves. In many traditions the Prophet prayed for those who listened to his traditions and then reported them to others. For example, Bukhārī in his Ṣaḥīḥ narrates that the Prophet said: ‘The one present has to relate to the one absent, because there might be some people among those absent who can understand better than those who are present.’21
Indeed, many companions of the Prophet, as well as all the great traditionists, such as Imām Ahmad b. Ḥanbal, Muslim and Bukhārī who came later and compiled the ḥadīths of the Prophet and even the sayings of his Companions and those who followed them (al-tābi‘ūn), felt responsible for recording ḥadīths and putting them at the disposal of others. This was one of the means by which Islamic culture could spread and spread. The teachings of the Prophet were needed not only by those who had direct access to him and could learn them from him, but also by all those who came after them.
It deserves to be mentioned here that from the outset the Shī‘a paid great attention to the Sunnah of the Prophet and were determined to record his traditions, as a prerequisite for proper practice and delivery of his message, even though some of them lost their lives in doing so and others were imprisoned.
The Sunnah and the Household of the Prophet
We turn now to the role of the Household of the Prophet in presenting Islam. This will involve two topics: the justification for considering the Household of the Prophet as a reliable source in understanding Islam, and the necessity of adhering to their teachings in understanding Islam.
With respect to the first topic, there is no disagreement among Muslims about the validity of following the teachings of the household of the Prophet in understanding Islam. This includes the Sunnis, who also consider all the Companions of the Prophet as reliable sources for understanding Islam.22
The justification for following the teachings of the Household of the Prophet becomes even clearer when we refer to the traditions from the Prophet about his household, and examine sayings of Sunni scholars about the knowledge of ‘Ali and other members of the household of the Prophet. For example, Abū Ḥanīfah says: ‘If it were not for those two years, I would surely have been destroyed.’ Those ‘two years’ were the period he spent studying with Imām Ja’far Ṣādiq, the sixth Imām, and attending his lectures.23 Imām Mālik says: ‘No eyes have seen, no ears have heard, and nothing has come to the heart of any human being better than Ja‘far b. Muḥammad in his knowledge, in his piety, in his asceticism and in his servitude to God.’ This is what Ibn Taymīyah reports from Imām Mālik.24 There is no ambiguity in these statements, which is why many Sunni scholars have clearly pointed out that every Muslim is allowed to act according to one of the five Islamic schools of jurisprudence (fiqh): Ja‘farī, Ḥanafī, Ḥanbalī, Mālikī and Shāfi‘ī.
The reason for this is clear: even if Imām Ja‘far Ṣādiq or other members of the Household of the Prophet did not possess more knowledge or better access to the knowledge of the Prophet than others, one has to admit that he must have been at least equal to others, especially if he is said to have taught them. People who are educated or who are seeking the truth are expected, therefore, to examine all Islamic sources available, and thus come to a conclusion about the ways Muslims can lead exemplary lives. Certainly one rich source is the teachings of the Household of the Prophet. Historically, however, for one reason or another, perhaps because of some kind of pressure, not all scholars fully conveyed the traditions of the Household of the Prophet.
It is thus quite clear that whoever tries to understand Islam and the Sunnah of the Prophet can refer to the teachings of his Household.
Now let us see whether it is necessary to refer to the Household of the Prophet in order to understand Islam or whether it is simply a matter of choice. In answering the question we will focus on some traditions from the Prophet narrated by great Sunni traditionists and accepted by both Sunni and Shī‘a scholars. It must first be noted, however, that all the teachings of the Household of the Prophet were always based on the Glorious Qur’ān and the Sunnah of the Prophet. No one should think that, for example, Imām Ṣādiq said something concerning Islam based on his own opinion. Whatever he and the other Imāms uttered was exactly what they had themselves received from the Prophet. There are many traditions in this regard. For example, in Uṣūl al-Kāfī we find that Imām Ṣādiq proclaimed that whatever he said was what he had received through his forefathers from the Prophet. This is a crucial point: all the traditions of Imāms were received directly from the Prophet.
One of the traditions indicating the necessity of following the Household of the Prophet is the famous tradition of Thaqalayn. This tradition was uttered by the Prophet on several different occasions, including the day of ‘Arafah in his last pilgrimage and the 18th of Dhū al-Ḥijjah at the location known as Ghadīr Khumm. Despite minor differences in the wording, the content is the same in all versions of the tradition. For example, in one version the Prophet is recorded to have said:
O people! I leave among you two precious things: the Book of God and my Household. As long as you hold on to them you will not go astray.
Or in another version the Prophet is reported to have said:
I leave among you two precious things; if you hold on to them, you will not go astray after me: the Book of God, which is like a rope extended between the heaven and the earth, and my Household. These two things will not separate from each other until they reach me near the fountain on the Day of Judgement. Be alert and careful how you treat them after me.
This shows that the Prophet was worried about the way that Muslims, or at least some of them, would treat the Qur’ān and his Household. In another tradition he said:
I leave two successors: one is the Book of God, which is like a rope extended between heaven and the earth, and the second is my Household. They will not separate from each other until they come to me near the fountain of Kawthar.
The above traditions can be found in major Sunni sources, such as Ṣaḥīḥ of Muslim (Vol. 8, p. 25, no. 2408), Musnad by Imām Ahmad (Vol. 3, p. 388, no. 10720), Sunan by Dārimī (Vol. 2, p. 432) and Ṣaḥīḥ by Tirmidhī (Vol. 5, p. 6432, no. 3788). They are also mentioned in books such as Usd al-Ghābah by Ibn al-Athīr (Vol. 2, p. 13), Al-Sunan al-Kubrā by Bayhaqī (Vol. 2, p. 198) and Muttaqī al-Hindī’s Kanz al-‘Ummāl (Vol. 1, p. 44).
The meaning of the ḥadīth is clearly that the Prophet has left among Muslims two weighty things: the Qur’ān and his Household, and that as long as people hold on to them both, they will not go astray. This shows that these two things must always be in harmony with each other and that they never contradict each other. Otherwise, the Prophet would not have given the people the instruction to follow both of them; they would be bewildered if the household of the Prophet were to tell them to go in one direction and the Book of God told them to go in another. Although this is implied at the very beginning of the ḥadīth, the Prophet himself made it explicit by concluding, ‘They will not separate from each other until they come to me near the fountain of Kawthar.’
Thus, this ḥadīth in all its versions indicates that:
From the time of the Prophet until the end of the world the Book of God and the Household of the Prophet will always be together.
No one can say that the book of God is enough and that we do not need the Household of the Prophet, or vice versa, for the Prophet clearly said: ‘I leave two precious things that you must grasp and if you do so you will not be misled.’
The Household of the Prophet never make mistakes and they are always truthful.
Just like the Qur’ān, the Household of the Prophet will enjoy a type of continuity until the Day of Judgement when they will join the Prophet near Kawthar. Thus, the Household of the Prophet will never disappear, even for a short period of time.
The other ḥadīth is known as the ḥadīth of Safīnah.25 Sunni and Shī‘i traditionists alike have narrated that the Prophet said:
Be aware that surely the parable of my household among you is like the ship of Noah. Whoever embarked on the ship of Noah was saved and whoever refused to do so was drowned.
In another tradition the Prophet adds something else. After comparing his Household to the ship of Noah, he also likened it to the Gate of Ḥiṭṭah for the tribes of the Children of Israel, ‘whoever entered by which was forgiven by God’. (Qur’ān, 2:58) This means then that whoever enters the knowledge and advice of his Household and is modest and humble towards them, will be forgiven by God and be guided. Ibn Ḥajar, a great Sunni scholar, maintains that the reason for the Prophet’s comparing his household to the ship of Noah is that whoever loves and respects the Household of the Prophet and grasps the guidance of the knowledgeable men of that Household will be saved from the darkness of conflict and disagreement, while those who refuse to be with the Household of the Prophet will be drowned in the sea of ingratitude for divine blessing and be destroyed. Then he goes on to explain why the Prophet compared his Household to Bāb al-Ḥiṭṭah. Ibn Ḥajar says that according to the Qur’ān whoever enters this Bāb al-Ḥiṭṭah (which might be the gate either of Jericho or of Jerusalem [Bayt al-Maqdis]) with humility and asks forgiveness from God will receive it. He concludes that as entrance through this gate led to forgiveness for the tribes of the Children of Israel, following the teachings and advice of the Household of the Prophet will lead to forgiveness for the Islamic nation (Ummah).26
In another tradition, the Prophet compared his Household to stars in the sky that help travellers to find their way:
Stars save people from being drowned, and my Household saves people from disagreement and conflicts. If a group of Arabs people disagree with my Household they will suffer disagreements among themselves; they will lose their unity and become the party of Satan.27
The ḥadīth of Safīnah in its different versions thus emphasizes the same importance of the Household of the Prophet as the ḥadīth previously cited. It can be found in different Sunni books, such as the Mustadrak of Ḥākim Nīshābūrī, Vol. 3, pp. 149 and 151, Arba‘īn Ḥadīth of Nawbahānī and al-Sawā‘iq al-Muḥriqah by Ibn Ḥajar.
According to these traditions, following the guidance of the Household of the Prophet is of the utmost necessity; those who refuse to do so will be unable to find the right direction and will drown in the sea of ignorance, conflict and disagreement.
We thus conclude that it is valid to resort to the traditions of the household of the Prophet in understanding what the Prophet meant and mentioned, and that it is indeed necessary to do so.
Note: The tradition of Thaqalayn is mentioned in both Sunni and Shī‘a sources and is therefore accepted by all Muslims. However, in one version of the ḥadīth the Prophet is quoted as saying ‘my Sunnah’ instead of ‘my Household.’ Although this version can be found only in some Sunni sources, there is no difficulty in understanding what this tradition means, assuming this version to be authentic. The Prophet in many traditions narrated by all Muslims has said: ‘I am leaving two precious things, and those are the glorious Qur’ān and my Household’, whereas in a few traditions narrated by one group of Muslims only he is reported to have said: ‘the glorious Qur’ān and my Sunnah’. Obviously the conclusion to be drawn is that as one side of the Comparison is the same, i.e. the Qur’ān, the other side too must be identical. Therefore, ‘my Sunnah’ and ‘my Household’ must be identical, for otherwise one would have to say that the Prophet contradicted himself. Referring to the teachings and advice of the Household of the Prophet is thus identical to referring to the Sunnah of the Prophet. The only way to gain perfect access to the Sunnah of the Prophet and to understand it precisely is to refer to those who had the closest relationship with him and knew better than anyone else what he said or did or approved.
Who Constitutes the Household of the Prophet?
Another question concerns the exact meaning of ‘the Household’. In the numerous traditions that enjoin upon us adherence to the Household of the Prophet, they are referred to as Ahl al-Bayt or al-‘Itrah. What do these terms refer to and what persons are encompassed in the scope of the Household of the Prophet? Does it include any and all relatives of the Prophet? Three separate points will be made in answer to these questions, although each point might be regarded as conclusive in itself. Of course, there is no doubt among Muslims that Fāṭima, the daughter of the Prophet, Imām ‘Ali, and their sons, Imām Ḥasan and Imām Ḥusayn, belonged to the Household of the Prophet. The only question is whether other relatives of the Prophet may be included in that category or not and, if so, to what extent. Some Sunni Muslims believe that all relatives of the Prophet should be included, excluding of course those who did not embrace Islam, such as Abū Lahab, an uncle of the Prophet who was at the same time one of his bitterest enemies and was accordingly cursed in the Qur’ān. Shī‘a Muslims, by contrast, believe that the Household of the Prophet are only those persons who have levels of faith and knowledge that make it possible for them to be mentioned together with the Qur’ān in the Thaqalayn and other traditions. Moreover, they believe that the Prophet himself has clearly defined the members of his Household.
First Point
Whenever we have doubts about the scope of something such as a rule or a concept, but we know that it is necessarily true to a certain limit, beyond which it comes into question, we must exercise caution and observe only the minimum. For example, suppose that someone is uncertain whether in his prayer at the beginning of the first two units (rak‘ah), he can recite only the Sūrat al-Fātiḥah or whether he can recite other chapters of the Qur’ān as well. Reason determines that he should be cautious and must recite that which he is certain about – the Sūrat al-Fātiḥah. Now in our case if someone has a doubt concerning the scope of the term Ahl al-Bayt or similar terms, he is rationally obliged to restrict himself to the minimum concerning which he is certain. So if one is in doubt whether God approves of reference to people other than Fāṭima and her family, together with the Qur’ān, as part of the Household of the Prophet, reason instructs one to be cautious and to limit oneself to those people who are definitely included in the scope of the term.
Second Point
We saw earlier that the Household of the Prophet have been given a very high position. The Prophet has mentioned them as being next to the Qur’ān: ‘I leave among you two weighty things, the Qur’ān and my Household, and they will not separate from each other.’ So the Household of the Prophet are always with the Qur’ān and always will be; they will never contradict each other. Bearing this criterion in our mind, let us examine the early history of Islam in order to find among the relatives of the Prophet those who conform to it.
The only people to whom the Prophet have referred as his trust and as being collectively a partner of the Qur’ān are ‘Ali, his wife, Fāṭima, and their offspring. No Muslim, whether Sunni or Shī‘a, claims that other relatives of the Prophet had greater knowledge or piety than this family or served Islam more than they did. Moreover, no one can say that the expression ‘Household of the Prophet’ can include all relatives of the Prophet, for some of them, such as Abū Lahab, were disbelievers and even those who believed in Islam were not all at the same level. Many of them were very ordinary people and accepted Islam quite late. Indeed, the only people for whom this position of permanently accompanying the Qur’ān (in other words, ‘infallibility’) is claimed, are Fāṭima and her family. Similarly, if a Muslim be asked who could be infallible, he will either mention this group, in accordance with Shī‘a belief, or no one at all, because the non-Shī‘a do not claim infallibility for any group of people other than the prophets. To put it differently, he will not put forward anyone else as constituting a permanent accompaniment to the Qur’ān.
Here we are not presenting a circular argument to the effect that these people are infallible because the Shī‘a claim them to be so. The issue of infallibility will be discussed later in its own right. Our argument here is that, according to the traditions of the Prophet, there must necessarily be a group of his family who will be always with the truth, and since this position has been claimed exclusively for these persons, it is clear that the Prophet had in mind those for whom alone infallibility has been asserted. If the non-Shī‘a were to claim that some people other than those identified by the Shī‘a were infallible, one would have to adjudicate between the two claims. However, this is not the case, and if the tradition of the Prophet is to make any sense, the Shī‘a position seems therefore to provide the only solution.
Third Point
The Prophet himself has clarified what he meant by his Ahl al-Bayt or al-‘Itrah. This is reflected in the following ḥadīths found in major Sunni sources:
1. Muslim narrates from ‘Āyishah:
The Prophet went out wearing a black woollen cloak, when Ḥasan the son of ‘Ali, came to him, so the Prophet let Ḥasan come in with him under the cloak. Then Ḥusayn came and he too entered. Then Fāṭima came. She entered as well. Then ‘Ali came. He also went under the cloak, such that the cloak covered the Prophet, ‘Ali, Fāṭima, Ḥasan and Ḥusayn. Then the Prophet recited: ‘God only desires to keep away impurity from you, O People of the House! and to purify you a [thorough] purification.’ (33:33)28
2. Muslim narrates from Sa‘d b. Abī Waqqās that he was asked by Mu‘āwīyah why he refused to abuse ‘Ali verbally. Sa‘d replied: ‘I remember three sayings of the Prophet about ‘Ali, which caused me not to say anything bad about him. If I possessed even one of these qualities it would be better for me than red camels.’29 The first was that, when the Prophet wanted to go to the war of Tabūk, he left ‘Ali in Medina. ‘Ali was very sad that he was not fortunate enough to join the army and fight for the sake of God. He went to the Prophet, saying: “Do you leave me with the children and women?” The Prophet replied: “Are you not happy to be to me, as Aaron was to Moses, except that there will be no prophet after me?” Second is what I heard from the Prophet on the day of the conquest of Khaybar: “Certainly I will give the flag [of Islam] to a man who loves God and His Messenger and is loved by God and His Messenger.” We hoped to be given the flag, but the Prophet said: “Call ‘Ali for me!” ‘Ali came forward, although he was suffering from pain in his eyes. The Prophet gave him the flag and at his hands God granted us victory. The third instance is that when the verse of Mubāhalah was revealed the Prophet called ‘Ali, Fāṭima, Ḥasan and Ḥusayn and said: “My Lord! These are my household.”30
3. Muslim narrates that some people asked Zayd b. Arqam to tell them what he had heard from the Prophet. He said: ‘I have become very old and it was a long time ago. I have also forgotten some of what I knew from the Prophet. So whatever I tell you accept it, and whatever I do not tell you, do not force me to tell it.’ Then he said that once the Prophet stood speaking to us in a place between Mecca and Medina called Khumm. The Prophet started by praising God and preaching. Then the Prophet said: ‘O people! Know that I am a human being and soon a messenger from my God [the angel of death] will call me and I will answer him. Surely, I am leaving among you two precious things. The first is the Book of God, in which there is guidance and light, so hold on to the Book of God.’ Having encouraged and urged the people to do so, the Prophet then said: ‘and the second is my household’. He added (three times): ‘I ask you to remember God in [the way you treat] my Household.’ Then Ḥusayn b. Ṣubrah said: ‘O Zayd! Who are the Household of the Prophet? Are his wives included?’ Zayd replied that the wives of the Prophet are his relatives, but his Household are those who cannot accept charity (ṣadaqah), and his wives do not have such a position. Then the person asked: ‘So who are they?’ Zayd replied: ‘The family of ‘Ali [the cousin of the Prophet], the family of Aqil [the brother of ‘Ali], the family of Ja‘far [the other brother of ‘Ali] and the family of ‘Abbās [the uncle of the Prophet and ‘Ali].’31
4. Under the same heading Muslim mentions another version of the ḥadīth, the beginning of which is the same as the one mentioned above, but the end of which is different. According to this version, in response to the question of whether the wives of the Prophet were included in his household, Zayd b. Arqam says: ‘No, I swear by God. A wife lives with her husband for a period of time and then she may get divorced and return to her own father and family. The Household of the Prophet are only those who are from the same root and origin as the Prophet and those who are prohibited to take charity [even] after the Prophet.’32
Thus, the expression ‘Household of the Prophet’ (Ahl al-Bayt) does not include all the relatives of the Prophet. The wives of the Prophet are not considered as belonging to the Household in this particular sense, although they are members of his family and much respected. According to ḥadīths, the expression Ahl al-Bayt or al-‘Itrah has a specific and limited sense.
Based on ḥadīths, Shī‘a scholars believe that every descendant of Hāshim, the great-grandfather of the Prophet, is in a sense his Household and called ‘Sayyid’. There are certain rules in Islamic jurisprudence pertaining to them, such as prohibition of taking charity. But again according to ḥadīths and the above arguments, the term Ahl al-Bayt in its Qur’ānic sense and in the sense used in the Prophetic ḥadīths such as those of Thaqalayn, Safīnah and the cloak is more limited, for it applies only to Fāṭima, ‘Ali, Ḥasan and Ḥusayn and then to other Imāms of his Household.
5. Imām Ahmad b. Ḥanbal narrates from ‘Umar b. Maymūn that he said: ‘We were sitting next to Ibn ‘Abbās, the cousin of the Prophet and a great scholar. A group of nine people came to him and asked him either to go with them or to ask the people present to leave the place. Ibn ‘Abbās went with them. After a while, Ibn ‘Abbās came back very angry because of the bad things that he had heard from them about ‘Ali.’ The narrator adds that then Ibn ‘Abbās started to describe the position of ‘Ali in the eyes of the Prophet and some of his merits. He mentioned the conquest of Khaybar by ‘Ali and the announcement of the revelation of Sūrat al-Tawbah to the polytheists by ‘Ali.33 Then he mentioned another event in which the Prophet addressed his cousins and asked: ‘Who among you is prepared to believe in me and follow me in this universe and hereafter?’ Imām Ahmad says that all the cousins of the Prophet refused to give a positive response. There was only one positive answer and that was from ‘Ali. This question and answer was repeated once more in the same session. Finally the Prophet said: ‘You are my walīy (vicegerent) in this world and the hereafter.’ Ibn ‘Abbās also mentioned that ‘Ali was the first man who embraced Islam.
The other event that Ibn ‘Abbās mentioned and is fully relevant to our discussion here is that the Prophet took his cloak, covered with it Fāṭima, ‘Ali, Ḥasan and Ḥusayn and recited the verse: ‘God only desires to keep away impurity from you, O People of the House! and to purify you a [thorough] purification.’ (33:33)34
6. Al-Tirmidhī narrates that ‘Umar b. Abī Salāmah, who was a stepson of the Prophet, reported from his mother, Umm Salāmah, that the Prophet asked ‘Ali, Fāṭima, Ḥasan and Ḥusayn to come under his cloak, and that he then said: ‘O God! These are my Household [Ahl al-Bayt]. Remove all uncleanliness from them and purify them a [thorough] purification!’ Then God revealed the verse (33:33) to his Prophet. Umm Salamah says: ‘I was there and I asked the Prophet: Am I one of your household?’ The Prophet replied: ‘You have your own place, you are good.’35 Thus, the Prophet confirmed her value, but not as a member of Ahl al-Bayt.
7. Imām Ahmad b. Ḥanbal narrates from Anas b. Mālik that when the verse of taṭhīr (33:33) was revealed, for six months the Prophet used to call at the house of ‘Ali and Fāṭima every morning on his way to the mosque for the dawn prayer of and call out:: ‘Prayer, O People of the House!’36
There are also traditions clarifying the meaning of the expression al-Qurbā (‘near ones’), which occurs several times in the Qur’ān, as when the Prophet is instructed to ask not for any payment in return for his teachings but only that people should love his Qurbā (42:23).37 Zamakhsharī, a great Sunni scholar and exegete of the Qur’ān, says that when this verse was revealed the Prophet was asked who are meant by this verse. The Prophet replied: ‘Ali, Fāṭima and their two sons’.38
The Reason
The Shī‘a believe that the reason is a reliable source of knowledge and that it is in complete harmony with revelation. According to some ḥadīths, God has two proofs (ḥujjah) by means of which humans can understand His will: the internal one, reason (al-‘aql), and the external one, the prophets. Sometimes reason is called ‘the internal prophet’ and the prophets are called ‘the external reason’. There is an established rule among Shī‘a jurists that whatever judgement is made by reason is the same as that made by religion (shar‘) and vice versa. It is also unanimously accepted that one of the conditions of moral or legal responsibility is to have sound reason. If someone is insane, he is not considered as responsible for his acts. What is expected of people in religion also varies according to their mental and rational capacity. Those with a higher degree of intelligence or learning are expected to be more knowledgeable, pious and obedient than those who are uneducated or ignorant. For example, according to a divine saying (ḥadīth al-qudsī), God rewards and punishes people in proportion to their reason.
According to the Qur’ān, God requires all human beings to exercise their rational faculty and to ponder on His signs and communications in the universe. On many occasions disbelievers are condemned and criticized because of their failure to think or to act according to rational requirements. For example, they are condemned because of their blind imitation of their ancestors, and there are many verses containing rhetorical questions calling on people to think, such as: ‘Do not they think?’ or ‘Do not they ponder?’
In general, reason contributes to religious sciences in three major areas. The first is the understanding of the realities of the world, such as the existence of God, the truth of religion and scientifically established truths. The second is the presenting of moral and legal principles, such as the wrongness of oppression and the rightness of justice. The third is the setting up of standards and logical processes for reasoning and inference. All three roles of reason are recognized and even encouraged in Islam.
It is reason that takes the first step towards religion, enquiring into it and searching for its truth. It is reason that drives us to take the issue seriously and tells us that our interests will be harmed if the claims of religion are true but yet we fail to discover them and to believe in them.
Once we have started our researches and investigations, it is again reason that instructs us how to think and how to argue. It is also reason that tells us to be fair, pious, truth-seeking and committed to the truth during and after the entire process of rational discovery. We cannot say that one must believe in God or Islam because God says so or because the Qur’ān requires it. We cannot even say that one has to investigate the truth of religion because the religion itself tells us to do so. It is reason that urges us to enquire about religion and thereby discover the veracity of the Qur’ān and the Prophet. Reason thus has a crucial role with respect to religious belief. Everyone must make his or her own enquiry regarding religion and discover the truth independently, and no one can rely on others. Of course, once the truth of a given prophet or book is established, many further truths can be learnt from that prophet or that book.
In respect of practical laws and moral values, the relevant principles are understood by reason. Details are, of course, provided by religious sources, although the process of understanding the scriptures and the implications of religious judgements again is governed by reason. For example, if God says that you must perform Ḥajj (the pilgrimage to Mecca), the rational implication is that we must make all necessary preparations, such as buying tickets or obtaining a visa. If there is a conflict between two obligations such as saving an innocent life and performing our prayers, what should we do? In this case, even if there is no explicit or particular religious instruction we still understand that we must act according to the certain and clear judgement of our reason, which is to save the person’s life.
In contrast, the role of revelation or scripture in religious sciences can be summed up as follows:
confirming truths that are already known by reason;
presenting new subjects not known by the reason, such as the details of the resurrection and detailed injunctions of moral and legal systems;
establishing due recompense sanctions through the religiously determined system of reward and punishment.
It should also be mentioned that having verified the truth of the Prophet or the Qur’ān, we come to know many things that we were unable to know by ourselves, because of our lack of access to certain realms of reality or certain evidence. One must therefore distinguish between what lies beyond one’s actual rational capacity and what conflicts with rational standards. The first case concerns matters that are entirely possible, for it corresponds to our experience in our everyday life and we know, too, that our ability to understand may gradually increase. The second case concerns matters that are impossible. In short, there is nothing irrational in Islam. Of course, one has to distinguish between certain and decisive rational judgements, on the one hand, and speculative or personal opinions, on the other. If in a given case it seems that rational judgement is in conflict with a religious ordinance, one must investigate where the error lies: either it was not a truly or accurately rational judgement or it was not a religious law. God never misleads people by telling them to do one thing through the prophets, and the opposite thing through their God-given reason. There have often been some judgements attributed to reason and taken as contradicting religious positions, which after close examination have proven contrary, in fact, to decisive rational premises.
M. R. Muzaffar in his commentary on reason says the following:
We believe that Allah has endowed us with the faculty of the intellect (‘aql), and that He has ordered us to ponder over His Creation, noting with care the signs of His Power and His Glory throughout the entire universe as well as within ourselves. It is stated in the Qur’ān: ‘We shall show them Our signs on the horizons and in themselves, till it is clear to them that it is the Truth.’ (41:53)
Allah has shown His disapproval of those who blindly follow the ways of those who were before them: ‘They say: “No, but we will follow such things as we found our fathers doing.” What! And if their fathers had no understanding of anything?’ (2:170)
And He has shown His dislike for those who follow nothing but their own personal whims: ‘They follow naught but an opinion.’ (6:116)
Indeed, our intellect forces us to reflect upon Creation so as to know the Creator of the universe, just as it makes it necessary for us to examine the claims of someone to prophethood and to consider the truth of his miracles. It is not correct to accept the ideas of someone without criticism, even if that person has the gift of great knowledge or holds an esteemed position.
Consensus
Traditionally one of the sources of understanding Islam is considered to be consensus (ijmā‘). According to the Shī‘a methodology of thought, the consensus of all people or a group of people, such as the scholars, is not sufficient by itself to serve as a proof (ḥujjah), for just as one person may make a mistake, two, three, thousands or even all of them may do so. However, whenever there exists an agreement among all Muslims or Muslim scholars such that it unveils the Sunnah, it can serve as a proof, as an instrument to discover the will of God. For example, when we find that all Muslims in the time of the Prophet said their prayers in a certain way we realize that the Prophet had instructed them to do so; otherwise there would be no factor accounting for their uniformity of action. It is impossible to imagine that they all acted blindly and without instruction, or that they were all in error and the Prophet failed to correct them.
Thus, for the Shī‘a consensus is not a proof in itself; it is authoritative only when it leads to the discovery of the Sunnah. Accordingly, if Muslims today agree on a given subject, a scholar who has doubts on the same subject cannot permissibly suppress them by invoking the view of the majority and conforming to it. There have been many cases in the history where all human beings held a belief that later turned out to be wrong, for example that the earth is flat. It is only the Qur’ān and the Sunnah that are unquestionably true and immune from any error or mistake. This approach grants a type of dynamism to Shī‘i thought, so that every generation of scholars – in fact, each individual scholar – is able and indeed required to refer directly to the Qur’ān and Sunnah and conduct original ijtihād, i.e. investigation and independent judgement. ijtihād has never been banned or terminated in the Shī‘a world. The Shī‘a believe that the view of no jurist, however high his position, is immune from scholarly questioning or rational challenge. Of course, as in any other discipline, every religious scholar needs to consult the works of his predecessors and examine them carefully.
Some Sunni Muslims believe that whenever in any age all Muslims or Muslim scholars agree unanimously on something, they must be right. It is possible that a person or a group of Muslims may make a mistake, but it is not possible that all of them should do so. They base this view on a ḥadīth they narrate from the Prophet: ‘My nation (Ummah) will never agree on an error.’
The Shī‘a believe that even if the authenticity of this ḥadīth is assumed, it has little practical effect or ability to settle debates or resolve doubts, because Muslim scholars rarely if ever agree on complicated questions for the solution of which no evidence can be adduced from the Qur’ān or the Sunnah. Moreover, the Shī‘a believe that there is always an infallible Imām among the Muslims; since he never errs, the Islamic nation taken as a whole will never agree on an error. The problem, of course, is to verify that all Muslims, including the infallible Imām, have held the same view on a given question.