ONE

Origins of Shī‘ism

The Meaning of the Term Shī‘a

Most languages have some terms that have two types of meanings: the original or primary and the technical or secondary. For example, the term ‘ṣalāt’ in Arabic originally just meant to supplicate, du‘ā. However, later on it acquired another meaning, i.e. a special type of worship in Islam that is known as ‘namāz’ in Persian and many other languages. Of course, as one can see in this case, there must be links and similarities between these two types of meaning.

In his Mu‘jam Maqāyīs al-Lughah, Aḥmad b. Fāris, a renowned philologist of the fifth Islamic century, examines the root of the term Shī‘a, i.e. sha-ya-‘a. He points out two meanings: to aid or help, and to spread. At least one of these two meanings must be found in all derivative forms of this root, whether they are used in their original sense or in their technical sense. For example, the Qur’ān (24:19) uses a derivative verb of this root to mean ‘to spread’.

The term ‘Shī‘a’ originally means one, two or a group of followers, in the sense that the followers of a given person are those who aid or help him or his causes. In the Glorious Qur’ān, this term is used several times in this sense. For example, in the verse 28:15 God speaks of one of the followers of Moses as one of his Shī‘a. Elsewhere, Abraham is introduced as a Shī‘a of Noah. (37:83)

The Technical Meaning of ‘Shī‘a’

At the beginning of Islamic history, the term Shī‘a was used in its original or general sense for followers of various people. For example, some ḥadīths speak of the ‘Shī‘a of ‘Alī b. Abī Ṭālib’ and others of the ‘Shī‘a of Mu‘awīyah b. Abī Sufyān.’ However, as we shall see later, the term gradually acquired a secondary or technical meaning, i.e. the followers of ‘Ali, those who believed in his Imāmate (divinely appointed leadership).

In many Arabic dictionaries, the term ‘Shī‘a’ is defined in both its literal and its technical meaning, such that it is easy to see the connection between the two, i.e. follower(s) in general and follower(s) of ‘Ali. The same is true of many theological sources. For example, Abu al-Ḥasan al-Ash‘arī (d. 330 AH) in his well-known Maqālat al-Islāmīyīn wa Ikhtilāf al-Muṣallīn comments on the technical meaning and says, ‘They were called Shī‘a only because they followed ‘Ali and believed that he was more privileged than other companions of the Prophet’.1

Shahrestānī (d. 548 AH) in his Al-Milal wa al-Niḥal, an outstanding source concerning different sects in Islam, writes, ‘Shī‘a are those who followed ‘Ali in particular and believed in his Imāmate and caliphate according to the explicit teachings and testament of the Prophet Muḥammad.’2 This is a very accurate definition, since the Shī‘a themselves believe that the reason for following ‘Ali is that it was required by the Prophet, and it was not their personal decision to choose whom to follow. By contrast, the non-Shī‘a, after the death of the Prophet Muḥammad, followed the one who was chosen at Saqīfah and believed that the Prophet had left it to the people themselves to decide whom to follow. However, Abū Bakr b. Abī Quḥāfah, the first Caliph, who himself was chosen in this way, believed that he must appoint his own successor. The second Caliph, ‘Umar b. al-Khaṭṭāb, in turn appointed a council of six people to choose one from among their number according to a very strict procedure he himself had set up. It is interesting to note that it was ‘Ali, the fourth Caliph, who was chosen and indeed compelled by nearly all Muslims after the murder of the third Caliph, 'Uthmān b. 'Affān, to undertake the position of caliphate.

In his Firaq al-Shī‘ah, al-Ḥasan b. Mūsā al-Nawbakhtī (d. 313 AH), a well-known Shī‘a scholar, writes, ‘the Shī‘a are the party of ‘Ali b. Abī Ṭālib. They were called ‘Shī‘a of ‘Ali’ during and after the life of the Prophet and are known as the followers of ‘Ali and believers in his Imāmate.’3 Shaykh al-Mufīd (d. 413 AH), one of the most outstanding early Shī‘a scholars, defines the Shī‘a as being those who follow ‘Ali and believe in his immediate successorship to the Prophet.4 Explaining why the Shī‘a are also called ‘Imāmīyah’, he says: ‘This is a title for those who believe in the necessity of Imāmate and its continuity in all ages, and that every Imām must be explicitly designated and must also be infallible and perfect.’5

Thus, it can be said that the Shī‘a are those who have the following beliefs about the successorship to the Prophet Muḥammad:

1. Successorship to the Prophet depends on divine appointment.

2. As the Prophet was chosen by God, his successor, the Imām, also must be chosen by God and identified by the Prophet.

3. The immediate successor to the Prophet Muḥammad was ‘Ali.

Non-Shī‘a or Sunni Muslims believe that the successorship to the Prophet is not a divine position, and accordingly those who succeeded the Prophet, the Caliphs, did not necessarily have to possess a high level of knowledge or spirituality; certainly they were not required to be the most knowledgeable and pious people of their age. In practice there have been some Caliphs whose acts did not even comply with Islamic standards. Neither were the shifts of power among Caliphs always morally acceptable.

What has been explained above is the most common usage of the term ‘Shī‘a’ throughout the history of Islam. In some of the old texts one may come across a somewhat different usage of the term. For example, some historians and authors of ḥadīth dictionaries of biographical narrators applied the term ‘Shī‘a’ even to those Sunni Muslims who believed that ‘Ali was superior in knowledge or faith or services to Islam to the third Caliph or to all of the first three Caliphs.

When Did Shī‘ism Start?

This is a question that naturally arises. The question can be divided into two sub-questions:

1. When was the first time that a group of people came to believe in the necessity of following ‘Ali as a divinely chosen successor to the Prophet? In other words, when did the idea of Imāmate start?

2. When did the term ‘Shī‘a’ acquire its technical meaning? In other words, when was the term ‘Shī‘a’ first applied to the followers of ‘Ali and believers in his Imāmate?

These questions are important, because it has been suggested that the Shī‘a faith was not rooted in Islam during its formative period during the life of the Prophet Muḥammad, and that this idea originated only later among certain people or nations such as the Iranians. There have been many scholarly works on the evaluation of these hypotheses and many of them are no longer taken seriously in the academic world. In the present work, we shall investigate the main Islamic sources to see when the idea of Imāmate started and when the term ‘Shī‘a’ was applied to the followers of ‘Ali for the first time. Once we have elucidated the historical facts, there will be no need to study alternative theories one by one.

There are many ḥadīths narrated by both Shī‘a and non-Shī‘a regarding the issue of Imāmate, which we shall study later when we discuss Shī‘a doctrines. In what follows, however, we shall study only those ḥadīths in which the Prophet Muḥammad spoke of a group of people as ‘Shī‘a’ (followers) of ‘Ali and then refer to some further ḥadīths and elements of the history of Islam that can shed more light on the present subject. All ḥadīths mentioned below are cited from respected Sunni sources. They are only samples of what is to be found in the sources mentioned here as well as others.

1. Ibn ‘Asākir (d. 571 AH) narrated from Jābir b. ‘Abdullāh al-Anṣārī that he said:

Once we were with the Prophet Muḥammad, when ‘Ali arrived, upon which the Prophet said, ‘I swear by Him Who has my life in His hand that surely this man and his Shī‘a will be happy on the Day of Resurrection’, and then the verse ‘Surely those who believe and do good deeds are the best of men’ (98:7) was revealed. Later, whenever the companions of the Prophet Muḥammad saw ‘Ali coming, they would say, ‘The best of men has come.’6

2. Al-Suyūṭī (d. 911 AH) narrated from Ibn ‘Abbās that when the verse (98:7) was revealed the Prophet told ‘Ali: ‘Those are you and your Shī‘a and on the Day of Resurrection you will be pleased and well-pleasing [God].’7

3. Ibn Ḥajar (d. 974 AH) narrated from Ibn ‘Abbās that when the verse (98:7) was revealed the Prophet told ‘Ali: ‘Those are you and your Shī‘a. You and your Shī‘a will come forth on the day of Resurrection while you will be pleased and well-pleasing [God] and your enemies will come while they will be angry and seized by their necks.’8

4. Ibn al-Athīr (d. 774) narrated that, addressing ‘Ali, the Prophet said:

‘O ‘Ali! You and your Shī‘a will reach God being pleased with Him and well-pleasing Him, and your enemies will reach Him, being angry and will be seized by their necks.’ Then the Prophet demonstrated how this would be by putting his hand on his neck.’9

There are other ḥadīths in which the Prophet Muḥammad, addressing ‘Ali, used the expression ‘our Shī‘a’. This is in line with what was asserted above, that the Shī‘a are those who follow ‘Ali, in accordance with the teachings of the Prophet and not because of their own personal decision. For example, Ibn ‘Asākir narrated that the Prophet said:

Surely there is a spring in Paradise sweeter than nectar, smoother than butter, cooler than ice, and which smells better than musk. In that spring is the clay (ṭīnah) from which we (my household and I) were created and our Shī‘a are made from the same clay.10

There are yet other ḥadīths in which the Prophet, addressing ‘Ali, used the expression ‘Shī‘a of your descendants’. This confirms what was suggested above, that the Shī‘a are those who follow ‘Ali because they believe in the institution of Imāmate. As we shall see in detail later, the Shī‘a believe that ‘Ali was the first Imām and after him Imāmate continued in the offspring of ‘Ali and Fāṭima, who were chosen by God and introduced by the Prophet. For example, Zamakhsharī (d. 538 AH) in his Rabī‘ al-Abrār reports that the Prophet said: ‘O ‘Ali! When the Day of Resurrection comes I will hold on to God, you will hold on to me, your descendants will hold on to you and their Shī‘a will hold on to them. Then you will see where we will be taken.’

It has to be noted that, according to the Qur’ān, prophethood was also inherited. The Qur’ān says: ‘And surely we have sent Noah and Abraham, and we placed prophethood and the Book in their offspring.’ (57:26) This means that those who were qualified to be chosen as prophets by God were included in their offspring. In the Qur’ān (2:124) there is an account of how Abraham who was already a prophet and khalīl-ullāh (God’s friend) was elevated by God to be an Imām for the people. Then Abraham asked God whether He would place Imāmate in his offspring as well. God replied that His covenant (here meaning Imāmate) would not reach those who would be unjust. In this way, Abraham realized that Imāmate would be inherited by his just and pious offspring.

In addition to the above-mentioned ḥadīths and their like and ḥadīths on Imāmate that will be mentioned later, there are many other reasons why the appearance of a group of people such as the Shī‘a in the lifetime of the Prophet was a very natural and even necessary phenomenon. For example, at the beginning of Islam when God asked the Prophet to start his public call to Islam by summoning his close relatives, the Prophet invited his relatives to a meal. After the meal the Prophet declared his mission and invited the guests to embrace Islam and said that whoever believed in Islam among them and assisted him would be his successor. All kept silent. The only one who accepted the invitation to assist him was ‘Ali, a teenager at that time. The Prophet asked him to sit and repeated his invitation for a second and a third time. Again and again it was only ‘Ali who expressed his readiness to support the Prophet. The Prophet accepted ‘Ali’s submission to the will of God and carried out Allah’s command to designate him as his successor. This event is documented in many sources.11

In a very important statement, the Prophet clearly affirmed that ‘Ali was truthful and free of false beliefs and wrong acts, be it in his personal conduct or in his speech and judgements, and implicitly asked Muslims to follow him. Umm Salamah reported that the Prophet said: ‘Ali is always with the truth (al-ḥaqq) and the Qur’ān and the truth are always with him, and until the Day of Resurrection they will never separate from each other.’ This particular ḥadīth is narrated by Ibn ‘Abbās, Abū Bakr, ‘Ā’ishah, Abū Sa‘īd al-Khuddarī, Abū Laylā and Abū Ayyūb al-Anṣārī as well.12 The Prophet is also quoted as saying, ‘May God bless ‘Ali. My Lord, make the truth always be with him.’13

The Prophet also asserted on several occasions that ‘Ali was the most knowledgeable among his men in matters pertaining to the Islamic sciences. For example, the Prophet said: ‘Wisdom is divided into ten parts: nine parts are given to ‘Ali and one part is distributed among the rest of the people.’14 Later the second Caliph reaffirmed the sayings of the Prophet by saying, ‘May God never afflict me with a difficult task where ‘Ali is not present.’15

One also has to take into account the valuable and vital services and sacrifices of ‘Ali, in order to be able to appreciate his position among Muslims. For example, when the infidels of Mecca planned to kill the Prophet and God informed him of their plot, the Prophet asked ‘Ali whether he would be willing to sleep in his place so that the pagans would think that he was still at home, allowing him to leave Mecca safely. ‘Ali accepted this task, at which the verse was revealed, ‘And among people are those who sell their souls to acquire divine pleasure.’ The migration of the Prophet from Mecca to Medina marks the beginning of the Islamic calendar. ‘Ali served the cause of Islam by fighting in the Battles of Badr, Uḥud, Khaybar, Khandaq and Ḥunayn, in all of which he played crucial roles. These are all recorded in numerous historical works and collections of ḥadīths made by non-Shī‘a scholars.

We conclude this part of the discussion by referring to the well-known ḥadīth of Ghadīr. Returning from his last pilgrimage to Mecca, the Prophet asked thousands of Muslims accompanying him to stop on the way. He stood on a platform or pulpit made for him out of saddles and said, ‘Whoever has adopted me as his master (mawlā), ‘Ali is now his master.’ Then the people present there, including the future first and second Caliphs, paid allegiance to ‘Ali and congratulated him. This ḥadīth is transmitted by more than one hundred sources. For a comprehensive list of non-Shī‘a sources of this ḥadīth, see numerous volumes of ‘Abaqāt al-Anwār by Mīr Ḥāmid Ḥusayn al-Hindī (d. 1306 AH) and Al-Ghadīr by ‘Abd al-Ḥusayn al-Amīnī (d. 1390 AH). Having affirmed the veracity of the ḥadīth, some Sunni writers have interpreted the term mawlā used in this ḥadīth to mean ‘friendship.’ Whether this can be accepted or not, there is no doubt that this tradition and the event gave ‘Ali a unique and central position among the Companions of the Prophet.

Thus, it seems that the different sets of ḥadīths together with the historical evidence mentioned above should leave no doubt that during the lifetime of the Prophet many Muslims came to love ‘Ali deeply, sought out his company and were determined to follow him after the Prophet. These people were so frequently and significantly referred to as the Shī‘a of ‘Ali that gradually the term ‘Shī‘a’ alone became equivalent to the Shī‘a of ‘Ali. More importantly, the idea of Imāmate of ‘Ali certainly started in the lifetime of the Prophet Muḥammad. The demise of the Prophet naturally brought the issue into focus and made those who still believed in the necessity of following ‘Ali distinct from other Muslims, who sooner or later came to believe in the institution of Caliphate as providing successorship to the Prophet in ruling Islamic society and not as a divine position. Describing events after the death of the prophet, Al-Mas‘ūdī (d. 345 AH), a great Sunni historian, writes: ‘Surely Imām ‘Ali and those of his Shī‘a who were with him stayed in his house at the time that the allegiance to Abū Bakr was made.’16

Later events, such as the wars that occurred during the Caliphate of ‘Ali and the tragedy of Karbalā in which the third Imām of the Shī‘a and 72 of his family and companions were killed, lent greater prominence to the Shī‘a of ‘Ali and influenced the formation of Shī‘a identity. For example, we find in one of the early works that ‘Ali, condemning Ṭalḥah and Zubayr, said: ‘Surely the followers of Ṭalḥah and Zubayr in Basra killed my Shī‘a and my agents.’17 Abū Mikhnaf (d. 158 AH) reports that after the death of Mu‘āwīyah the Shī‘a gathered at the house of Sulaymān b. Ṣurad and he told them: ‘Mu‘āwīyah has died; Ḥusayn has refused to pay allegiance to the Umayyads and has departed for Mecca; and you are his Shī‘a and the Shī‘a of his father.’18

There is an interesting remark made by Abū Ḥātam al-Sijistānī (d. 322 AH) in his Al-Zīnah: ‘The term “Shī‘a” was the first name that appeared in Islam for a denomination (madhhab) and it was the title for four companions of the Prophet: Abū Dharr, ‘Ammār, Miqdād and Salmān al-Fārsī. These four were also the most outstanding followers of ‘Ali.’ He also adds: ‘Later, at the time of the Battle of Ṣiffīn the term was applied to [all] followers of ‘Ali.’19

The Early Shī‘a

Naturally enough, Shī‘a Islam first started in the Ḥijāz among the companions of the Prophet. Referring to the Islamic historical and biographical works, we see that the list of the Shī‘a among the companions of the Prophet includes the following well-known members of the Banī Hāshim (descendants of Hāshim, great-grandfather of the Prophet Muḥammad): ‘Abdullāh b. al-‘Abbās, al-Faḍl b. al-‘Abbās, ‘Ubaydullāh b. al-‘Abbās, Quthām b. al-‘Abbās, ‘Abd al-Raḥmān b. al-‘Abbās, Tamām b. al-‘Abbās, Aqīl b. Abī Ṭālib, Abū Sufyān b. al-Ḥārith b. ‘Abd al-Muṭṭalib, Nawfil b. al-Ḥārith, ‘Abdullāh b. Ja‘far b. Abī Ṭālib, ‘Awn b. Ja‘far, Muḥammad b. Ja’far, Rabī‘at b. al-Ḥārith b. ‘Abd al-Muṭṭalib, al-Ṭufayl b. al-Ḥārith, al-Mughayrat b. Nawfil b. al-Ḥārith, ‘Abdullāh b. al-Ḥārith b. Nawfil, ‘Abdullāh b. Abī Sufyān b. al-Ḥārith, al-‘Abbās b. Rabī‘at b. al-Ḥārith, al-‘Abbās b. ‘Utbat b. Abī Lahab, ‘Abd al-Muṭṭalib b. Rabī‘at b. al-Ḥārith, Ja‘far b. Abī Sufyān b. al-Ḥārith. The list of Shī‘a among those companions of the Prophet who were not from the Banī Hāshim includes: Salmān, Miqdād, Abū Dharr, ‘Ammār b. Yāsir, Ḥudhayfat b. al-Yamān, Khuzaymat b. Thabit, Abū Ayyūb al-Anṣārī, Abu al-Haytham Mālik b. al-Ṭiḥān, Ubayy b. Ka‘b, Qays b. Sa‘d b. ‘Ubādah, ‘Adīy b. Ḥatam, ‘Ubādat b. al-Āmit, Bilāl al-Ḥabashī, Abū Rāfi‘, Hāshim b. ‘Utbah, ‘Uthmān b. Ḥunayf, Sahl b. Ḥunayf, Ḥakīm b. Jiblat al-‘Abdi, Khālid b. Sa‘īd b. al-‘Ās, B. al-Ḥusayb al-Aslamī, Hind b. Abī Hālat al-Tamīmī, Ja‘dat b. Hubayrah, Ḥujr b. ‘Adīy al-Kindī, ‘Amr b. al-Ḥamiq al-Khuzā‘ī, Jābir b. ‘Abdullāh al-Anṣārī, Muḥammad b. Abī Bakr (the son of the first Caliph), Abān b. Sa‘īd b. al-‘Asī, Zayd b. Ṣawḥān al-Zaydī.20

From the Ḥijāz, Shī‘a Islam first spread to Bilād al-Shām (approximately present-day Syria and Lebanon), especially Jabal ‘Āmil. The reason for this was that ‘Uthmān b. ‘Affān, the third Caliph, exiled the Prophet’s companion Abū Dharr to Damascus where Mu‘āwīyah was ruling. Abū Dharr did not keep silent, and went around Damascus and elsewhere in the region protesting against the deviations that had appeared in the Islamic world and summoning people to the love and support of ‘Ali. This great Companion of the Prophet went to Jabal ‘Āmil in southern Lebanon where he built two mosques and preached Shī‘i Islam. Shī‘i Islam was strengthened in Syria especially during the rule of the Hamdānid dynasty, particularly during the reign of Sayf al-Dawlah. The people of Ba‘albak (an ancient city in Lebanon, near the Syrian border) have also been Shī‘a from the very beginning of the history of Shī‘ism in Bilād al-Shām. Today it is one of the important centres of Shī‘a population in the region.

During the Caliphate of ‘Ali and after the Battle of Jamal, the city of Kufa in Iraq, originally founded for military purposes, became the capital of the Islamic state and of Shī‘ism as well.21 Shī‘ism developed and flourished in Kufa and from there spread to other parts of the world.

In Yemen, Shī‘ism is associated with the circumstances under which the people there embraced Islam. According to the history books, the Prophet first sent Khālid b. al-Walīd to Yemen to invite people to Islam. He stayed there for six months, but had no success. Then the Prophet sent ‘Ali and asked him to send Khālid back. Al-Burā’, who was a member of the delegation led by ‘Ali, says that when they reached the nearest part of Yemen, ‘Ali led the morning prayer and asked everyone to stand in one row. Then he advanced further towards the local people. ‘Ali first praised God, and then read the message of the Prophet to them. All the people of Hamdān embraced Islam on the very first day and were then followed by the other people of Yemen.22 Therefore, the Muslims of Yemen grew to have a great love for ‘Ali, especially later when they heard the merits of ‘Ali from the Prophet and witnessed the brutality of the enemies of ‘Ali, such as Busr b. Arti‘ah.

Shī‘i Islam in Egypt has a similar story, for from the first entrance of Islam into their country the Egyptians knew of Shī‘ism through contacts with great Companions of the Prophet who were involved in the event, such as Miqdād, Abū Dharr, Abū Rāfi‘ and Abū Ayyūb al-Anṣārī. During the time of the third Caliph, ‘Ammār b. Yāsir, a great Companion of the Prophet and an outstanding Shī‘a personality, visited Egypt. The Egyptians were very active in the events that compelled ‘Ali to accept the Caliphate after the murder of the third Caliph. When ‘Ali sent Qays b. Sa‘d to govern Egypt he was warmly welcomed and the people paid allegiance to him. Later ‘Amr b. al-‘Āṣ killed Muḥammad b. Abī Bakr, who had been appointed by ‘Ali as the next governor of Egypt. Under the Umayyad and ‘Abbāsid caliphates there was no Shī‘a rule in the country, but the people were sympathetic to the Shī‘i cause. This facilitated the establishment of Fatimid rule in Egypt and much of North Africa, which lasted until the time of Ṣalāḥ al-Dīn al-Ayyūbī who restored Sunni dominance of the region.23

In Iran, Shī‘ism had a different story. When they began to embrace Islam from the time of the second Caliph onwards, the majority of Iranians became Sunnis. Of course, for particular reasons some cities were from the very beginning Shī‘a in whole or in part, such as Qum, Rayy and Kāshān. The Buwayhids (ruled 320–447 AH), who were Shī‘a, had a great influence in the provinces of Iran and also in the capital of the Caliphate in Baghdad, and even upon the Caliph himself. This gave the Shī‘a the strength to practise and propagate their faith openly. When King Muḥammad Khudābandeh became Shī‘a in the seventh Islamic century, he gave greater prestige to the Shī‘a of Iran. A number of movements such as that of the Sarbedārids of Khurāsān also tended to popularize Shī‘ism. Finally, King Ismā‘īl established Safavid rule in 905 AH and made Shī‘ism the dominant school of thought in Iran. Since then, the overwhelming majority of Iranians have always been Shī‘a.

The growth of Shī‘i Islam in another country with a Shī‘a majority, the Republic of Azerbaijan, followed a similar course to Iran, since it used to be part of Iran until it was conquered by the Russians early in the 19th century.24 Islam entered Azerbaijan in the first Islamic century (642 CE) and since then Islam has always been the dominant religion there. Muslims now constitute more than 95 per cent of the population and the rest follow mostly the Russian Orthodox Church and the Armenian Apostolic Church. Seventy per cent of the whole population are Shī‘a. The process by which Shī‘ism became the dominant faith in Azerbaijan goes back to the early 16th century during the rule of the King Ismā‘īl, the founder of the Safavid dynasty.

Although the practice of Islam was restricted under Soviet rule, some of the people of Azerbaijan remained actively involved in religious affairs. There are many mosques, such as the Mosque of Tāzeh Pīr, the Jum‘ah Mosque and the Mosque of Imām Ḥusayn. There are also Islamic schools and seminaries, especially in Baku and Jalīl Ābād. It is customary for people to visit the tombs of Islamic saints, such as the tombs of the sisters of Imām Riḍā in Nādarān, the tomb of Bībī Heybat near Baku and the tomb attributed to the Prophet Jerjīs in Biljan. The people of Azerbaijan actively celebrate Islamic occasions. Every year in the month of Muḥarram (the first month in the Islamic calendar), especially on the 10th (Day of Āshūrā’) many processions and mourning ceremonies take place all around the country.